Savage content needs to be fixed.

[Vidu]

First: you can bypass the 1000-word-limit by editing your first post.

Second: I dont understand what your personal story as a person and a videogamer has anything to do with this...?

Third: Despite that story you dont seem to understand that this content is supposed to be run with a static. Those 4 instances in a game, that allows you to do anything you wish in what ever party composition you might desire, require you to form a static with 7 other people to continue on learning and clearing those fights each week. It is not supposed to be done via DF and PUGs - depending on the turn that might be possible, but its mostly designed with the idea of a static in mind.
Giving people who have already cleared it to go back and help others to clear it, but with the chest-penalty is a compromisse. Back in Coil-days you were locked out of any turn you had cleared (or rather: progressed by).

I agree that the tomestone-bonus isnt great, but you realise that that would also be a one-time-thing, right? You only get that once. So, the next week when you want to pug O5S you're left with nothing - you gave away that bonus-chest and need to look for a group regardless.

[Lord_Zlatan]

snip

you are 100% right. But what hes trying to say is that instead of new players (read: players that have tried an instance and havent cleared it [which doesnt mean they are incompetent]) being shunned, it would encourage players who have cleared it to allow a non clear player to enter and stick it out with them for that extra loot.