Well here is my ideas for tank gear build while avoiding crafted accorys:
Crit build most likely will be highest dmg one :
http://ffxiv.ariyala.com/11SL4 this give full 82 points from crit food and sad 19 points to DH-
Det build that use 345 wep so +1 attack power
http://ffxiv.ariyala.com/11NII
and tenecety build for lols:
http://ffxiv.ariyala.com/11P4D

as for dps i think crit > Det > tenecety will be in dps side of this builds but cant forget that 1880 tenecety build give around 4% more defence over other 2

Intresting side note is that crit build only need you to complete V1 and V2 savage and V3 for left side upgrade. Weapon upgrade will be hardest part.