I had personally sword oathed 100% of A9S-A11S when it was relevant... A12S I have watched dark knights go gritless the entire thing and the only thing stopping PLD was that our blocks did nothing for magic damage. Again if they try to make that extra mitigation a necessity, then they will make the content unclearable without a PLD which is bs to the other two tanks. Yes we need a DPS nerf, but we NEED DPS UTILITY, not HEALER/DEFENSIVE utility.