How would you change Nocturnal AST to be competitive against SCH?

[Ceasaria]

If I have to take my ideas from my thread adapted to our Astrologian, it would be this :


Shooting Star : "The Astrologian throws his cards (in his possession with Draw and/or Spread) and deals light damage in line in front of him with a potency of 150 [+ 100 x number of cards thrown] (max 350)."

Cast time : instant
Cooldown : 120 sec
Range : 25y
Radius : 3y


Collective Unconscious : "Creates a wheel of fortune around the caster, granting Regen and the effect ot the following cards for any party member who enters and stay inside it. Can only be executed when a Sect is active. Auto-attack ends upon execution. Effect ends upon using another action or moving. When the wheel of fortune disappears, the effects disappear as well."

- Diurnal Sect : The Bole, The Ewer, The Spire
- Nocturnal Sect : The Balance, The Arrow, The Spear

Cure Potency : 150
Duration : 15 sec.
Cast time : instant
Cooldown : 180 sec
Radius : 10y

[lulunami]

Nerf Scholar if you want competition to the so-called off-healer role. It is beyond broken and overpowered. Increase MP costs for Broil and nerf the fairy's healing potency. SE screwed up by creating the most overpowered job in the game. They cannot even nerf most of SCH's spells because it is shared with Summoner.

Scholar has no downsides. It basically has BLM's unlimited resources plus SMN's mobility.

[Zari]

Nerf Scholar if you want competition to the so-called off-healer role. It is beyond broken and overpowered. Increase MP costs for Broil and nerf the fairy's healing potency. SE screwed up by creating the most overpowered job in the game. They cannot even nerf most of SCH's spells because it is shared with Summoner.

Scholar has no downsides. It basically has BLM's unlimited resources plus SMN's mobility.

It really isn't broken.

Being really good at its role =/= broken.

It doesn't need nerfs. What it needs is a competitor for off healer, which might be found in the next expansion, hopefully

[Alistaire]

It really isn't broken.

Being really good at its role =/= broken.

It doesn't need nerfs. What it needs is a competitor for off healer, which might be found in the next expansion, hopefully

And nerfing it still wouldn't deal with the issue that diurnal AST is better than nocturnal by a longshot.

[FoxyAreku]

Collective Unconscious : "Creates a wheel of fortune around the caster, granting Regen and the effect ot the following cards for any party member who enters and stay inside it. Can only be executed when a Sect is active. Auto-attack ends upon execution. Effect ends upon using another action or moving. When the wheel of fortune disappears, the effects disappear as well."

- Diurnal Sect : The Bole, The Ewer, The Spire
- Nocturnal Sect : The Balance, The Arrow, The Spear

Cure Potency : 150
Duration : 15 sec.
Cast time : instant
Cooldown : 180 sec
Radius : 10y

I really like this, but lordy is that overpowered.