Curious on opinion. Smn or Mch. Which would you pick?

[Renryuu]

Yikes, I did not mean for this to be such a heated debate.

I was just curious as to if people were only given those 2 classes to play, which would they pick. Guess my rambling kinda messed that idea up. v_v

Well after reading everything I do have to wonder something as I noticed a few people mentioning groups using 2 melee. Would it be a good idea to level a melee like Ninja or Monk to bring their tools to the raid instead? I'd mention Dragoon but after seeing all they get on the way to 60, I don't think I could fit it all within an easily to reach manner, at least until I get a new G600 MMO mouse.

[RiceisNice]

Y...

Realistically speaking, if you're in a raid group with other people, you stick with one role. Freshly getting to lvl 60 will take some time to gear up one class, let alone two. If you're playing with a raid group, you shouldn't have to "have a melee class incase we don't need ranged", because you'd intially join the group as a ranged class to begin with.