Fantasia or Not Help people choose!

[Kukajoo]

im still to indecisive i have way too many au ra on my hands and i need to hunker down and pick one already
below are all my fav's i'd like as much feedback as possible please!!

1.2.3.4.
5.

[Kaelah]

Original look

I actually prefer the top one with all the changeable features off. I think the reason is in my opinion the limbal rings hide your eye colours. You can barely tell that you have one blue one green with the red over the top, but that's not necessarily a bad thing! Maybe you prefer subtle heterochromia. I think I'd prefer your characters eyes if they were a shade or two lighter of blue and green. It might make it more noticeable that your eyes are different colours with the red rings if they were brighter. Though personally I don't like the limbals as much with mismatched eyes. Again, just my opinion, but I feel it'd make her eyes stand out more. ^^ So to clear that up if I worded it confusing, if you want the limbals, try brighter shades of blue and green. Or stay the same without limbals. I like the face paint of your 2nd new image more than the tiger stripes too.

Hope that helps you in any way, I get the feeling you are a bit upset by some of the responses so I apologise if I have done the same. If you love your first creation go with that! She's certainly unique. :3

I'll add opinions on everyone else's tomorrow. o/

[Onikimaru]

Miqo'te (Current)



Au Ra



Female alts:

That second one

[KaijinRhada]

First, sorry if I missed anyone's postings and replies! Second, here are the opinions (and keep in mind they are only opinions :P) I have on the characters presented. Lots of tough choices here.

Now, I will say that as a general rule, especially if you are unsure, I would make an alt to run around and fight with to see if you like the feel and voice of the character. All are very crucial to enjoying your toon. I would also say to try and preview gear on them if possible. Another piece of advice as an artist, if you are really stuck on something with character creation, leave it for a bit, even leave the room! Come back to it ten or so minutes after with a fresh mind and eye, it'll help. As an example, it took me five iterations of characters running around to get to my current main.

Now for the reviews:

Silverhope: Tough choice: I think your Hyur has a certain quality and appeal to her that I can’t put my finger on; your Au Ra though has a nice exotic look as well. With your tweaks on you Hyur: The sea green eyes are really nice with dark hair.

Leep: Love your Elezen, but I think you should go Au Ra.

Kukajoo: So many variations, but I empathize with having so many choices on the go. Your Elezen is very unique, but so are your Au Ra. Of the ones you posted, I still like the one with the lime highlights and face 3.

Hivernica: Your second Au Ra is amazing.

Yamimarik: Both are quite nice, but I think I like your Hyur more.

Ashkendor: Change to the Au Ra, your use of face 2 is one of my favourites.

Mimilu: I really like your Roegadyn, but au ra 1 and 2 are also quite nice and stands out.

Lillia: Au Ra, it’s simple, but lovely.

Elim: I would go with Au Ra, second hairstyle, but hair is changeable. :P

EA9Sol: Tough call, though I really like your Miqo’te.

Zenaku: Au Ra!

Indiction: Flip a coin, both looks are great!

HarukoDK: Stay Roe, he looks fantastic.

jumanjilover89: Miqo’te!

Zumi: I think I like your miqo’te more.

Slipikin: Au Ra!

Shyluv: As you are considering switching back and forth and debating Wildwood or Duskwight, I would go Duskwight.

NintenPyjak64: I really like your Au Ra. With the gear, I would probably advise trying linked items with an alt, given their unique hourglass body shape. It can be troublesome when your equipment ends up looking less than stellar on a character.

Mahri: I think I like your Highlander more, very heroic looking.

Onikimaru: Miqo’te or male Au Ra is nice.

Keydah: Another tough choice! I would flip a coin, as both are very nice.

AzureZenorag13: I like your Miqo’te, but I think if you go Au Ra, I like the one with yellow limbal rings better.

Skeith-Adeline: Love your Highlander, I would stay.

Cyrus-Wallace: I always really liked your Highlander.

Raminax: I like your Raen. If you use a dark green for limbals, you can actually give the dark green eyes more dimension, but you do have to be careful with the tone on it.

Glaereth: Difficult decision here. I’m edging on the Miqo’te.

Mirakumi: I like your second Au Ra.

KaiKatzchen: I think I like your Miqo’te more.

Alleyia: Green eyed Au Ra! Or Au Ra 3. >.>

NorthernLapMSP: Au Ra 2 or 5.

Iromi: Au Ra!

Bizzarejelly5: I love your Miqo’te.

Noshpan: Both Au Ra are nice, though I do have you say I really like your Hyur.

Tachyon: Both are very nice (including the edits to your Miqo’te), leaning on the Au Ra.

FlareR: Au Ra! I love the colours.

DoctorSecksy: If you go an Au Ra, I would say your male Au Ra.

Priya: Both are nice, though I am leaning towards the Au Ra.

Akira: Au Ra!

MaethursXion: I like your splice of main and evil. For you alt, I would do the first.

Kaelah: Oh, this is hard as well. Coin flip!

Pomelo: Both are very nice.

Fuma: I would stay or go Elezen.

Velthice: I like the darker skin, though the light eyes are very nice.

xemogFC: Very nice Highlander, but your Au Ra is also quite lovely.

Colorful: I think I like your Miqo’te more.

Zerophilliac: I think Au Ra 2.

Red_X: Male Au Ra! Your Miqo’te is very nice though.

Mitsuyo: I like the first Au Ra.

Soyre_Monre: Au Ra!

Hildagarde: Elezen!

ToppeHatte: I like the simple and clean look of your Au Ra.

Norb: Both are very nice. I am leaning to the Roe, but it is a shame when there are no hairstyles you like with them.

Azure_dragon-: Hard choice, I would flip a coin.

Reokudo: I really like your Hyur, but with an Au Ra like that, you can’t go wrong with either. ^_^

Dhex: Au Ra!

Marveth: Loving the colour combo on the Au Ra.

Kouren: Au Ra!

KaijinRhada: Change to Au Ra. Soft(left) nose and skin3. Your miqote is pretty unique, but I think horns bring a lot to your look.

KaijinRhada - If you change I say: left nose. Skin 3. Hairstyle 2 or 3. If you stay cat then stay moony. I like the skincolour on that one more with the hair colour. Now my opinion... Draw. Sorrrrry! They both look so awesome I cannot decide. lol.

KaijinRhada: Au Ra, stronger nose, skin 2, hairstyle 2. Good job!

KaijinRhada: Mooncat!

Thank you all for your feedback! Oh boy, I'm still quite split on the choices. Between here and friends, it's a tie with the noses and skin 2 and 3. x.x

Also thanks for the compliments on my moonie! I think I will switch to Au Ra, but my mooncat will certainly be coming back as well, with alternating fantasias between the two (R.I.P. money). Miqo'te mannerisms are too cute to resist, and I am quite attached to the manqo'te.

[Elim]

im still to indecisive i have way too many au ra on my hands and i need to hunker down and pick one already
below are all my fav's i'd like as much feedback as possible please!!

1.2.3.4.
5.

I think the red haired one is the best. The darker, but interesting, red makes your eyes pop more. Those horns are my fave for males, too. The last picture is good too. I'd say it's my second favorite out of the bunch, but the green in the hair takes away from the eyes, imo.

[Sersei]

GAH! Why'd I have to find this thread a few minutes before work! Quickly:

Current me:



Miqo Maybe?



Au Ra Thoughts:

[Dhex]

oh wow, your characters are so pretty. how did you make the shadows render so nicely? :O

Ill-advised tinkering with driver profiles.

[silverhope]

2.

I think this the most soo brooding and sexy lol

[silverhope]

GAH! Why'd I have to find this thread a few minutes before work! Quickly:

Current me:


Miqo Maybe?

i really like the kitty havent really seen one like it

[Alleyia]

Played around with the character creator again and tried Mirakumis suggestion. I really, really like it! (Thank you so much )



Just for reference, the hairstyle in blonde/fairer skin/same eye colour and the yellow one:

And Feedback!

Silverhope: Your Au'ra is pretty cute, but I love the colour scheme of your Highlander (and Highlander are awesome!). Stay Highlander (for now!)

Leep: I like how your Au'ra looks similar to your Elezen, so though choice. But I think I like your Elezen a tiny bit more.

Kukajoo: So many choices!! But i quite like your Elezen.

Hivernica: Never change (even though your Au're is very, very pretty)! But your Elezen looks awesome!

Yamimarik: Hyur!

Ashkendor: Awesome job on your Au'ra's eyes! I'd say change!

Mimilu: Sorry to say, but no Au'ra comes even close to your pretty Roe! <3

Lillia: Change, love your eye colour on both characters though.

Elim: Love the natural colour selection of your Au'ra. I like your Miqo'te too, but for now I say: Fantasia and braided hair!

EA9Sol: Stay Miqo'te, the colours are awesomly powerful.

Zenaku: You should go for your Au'ra!

Indiction: Stay your handesome Miqo'te! ;o;

HakuroDK: The Au'ra nose is so thin! But it's a draw! Really can't decide which character I like more.

jumanjilover89: Though desicion, but I like your Au'ra more because she looks cool and unique!

Zumi: I like your Miqo'te more, even though your Au'ra is really pretty.

Slipikin: Au'ra!

Shyluv: Go back to your beautiful Duskwight! Never seen such a pretty Elezen before! <3

NintenPyjak64: Hmmm.....! Not easy either. But for now I'd say go for the Au'ra!

Mahri: I love them both!! Change to Au'ra! :>

Onikimaru: Your Miqo'te has lovely eyes, but the male Au'ra is really pretty aswell. Change! (The Female is nice aswell, but the male has something on him I really like)

Keydah: I like your Au'ra, but your Miqo'te has more "character" to her.

AzureZenorag13: As others have already said, your Au'ra has way, way to many colours that all clash together. The complimantary contrast doesn't work, because only one of the eyes are actually green/red. That kind of contrast can work of course, but only if there aren't that many colours used. I wouldn't use the limbal rings, or chose a colour that compliments your eyes (i.e. a light violett). Other than that, I still like your Miqo'te more! ^_^ She looks really unique and pretty!

Skeith-Adeline: Oh dear, so many pretty Au'ra and a really handsome Highlander! For now I'd say you should stay Highlander. But.. oh dear.. really not an easy desicion... ;o;

Cyrus-Wallace: Hmm.. as I really like the Au'ra Face you chose I'd say change!

Raminax: Nomnom, that Raen <3 I like the bright green more.

Glaereth: Those eyes scare me ;_; But other than that: Change!

Mirakumi: Au'ra! :>

KaiKatzchen: And I'd say Au'ra here aswell!

NorthernLadMSP: Go for the change, I like your first and second Au'ra the most!

Iromi: Change to Au'ra!

bizarrejelly5: I really like your Au'ra, I'd go for the change and switch back to your Miqo'te if you dislike it.

Nosphan: Stay Hyur, but change your male Miqo'te!

Tachyon: Hmm.. I like the Miqo'te better!

FlareR: Your Lalafell is awesomly handsome! But your Au'ra is one of my favourites thus far. This is one I really cannot decide, I'm sorry.

DoctorSecksy: Change to your male Au'ra!

Priya: Your Au'ra looks lovely, but your Hyur has something on her I like a lot more. For now I'd say, stay as your Hyur.

Akira: Change!

MeathusXion: The third Au'ra looks the best. I also like the first female Au'ra for your alt the most.

Kaelah: Stay your Miqo'te! It's one of my favourites! >o</

Pomelo: I like your Au'ra, but your Roe looks way better!

Fuma: Your current character looks pretty cool! Also fits your main-class. Stay as your current! (: (or the Elezen at the bottom)

KaijinRhada: I would pick the nose on the left side! Skin 2 and stick with the hairstyle. :P Aaaand Moonie!

zemogFC: I really like your Miqo'te the most!

Colorful: Your Miqo'te is way too cute to change her! :<

Zerophiliac: I like your Lala, but other than that I think your first Au'ra is the best

Red_X: Your male Au'ra as such a creepy smile! But still looks pretty cool! And I like the first
female Au'ra hair better.

Mitsuyo: I like your Au'ra! :>

Soyre_Monre: Your Au'ra looks very, very pretty, but also kinda standard. Not sure if it's because of the colourscheme or because of the default hairstyle.

Hildagarde: Don't switch, your Elezen looks awesome!

Blueyes: Your name fits your Au'ra. Change!

ToppeHatte: I like the look of your Miqo'te more. But the tomboyish look of your Au'ra is really well done too.

Norb: Stay Roe, but it's not an easy desicion either.. your Au'ra has something to her aswell..

Azure_dragon-: I really like how your Roe and your Au're share the same colourscheme I like them both alot! For now I'm saying: Change!

Reokudo: Handsome Highlander should stay handsome Highlander!

Dhex: Oh dear.. I like your Miqo'te, but your male Au'ra is so nice! Change! Same for your female Au'ra

Marveth: Change!

Kouren: I like your Miqo'te more, but thats also because it's one of my favourite faces ingame. But as you said youself, something on your Au'ra is still missing.. maybe try another eye-colour?

Sersei: I like the first and the second Au'ra the most and would change your Lala to one of those!

Phew...! Hope I didn't forget anyone! Sorry for my engrish, just really tired after a long day at work.