Quote Originally Posted by Wolfandre View Post
A dark secret, eh?

Had some shower thoughts the other day, so I didn't have my darksteel foil hat on at the time... But I'm starting to think that Halone and Shiva are the saaaaaame person. We don't have specific time period for when they both showed up in history. They're both heavily involved with Ishgard. Both are ice aligned.

Yep. Same person. Dark secret. You heard it here first (unless, of course, you heard it somewhere else first...or thought of that yourself).
Halone seemed to exist since the first astral era, they can't be the same.