Why is SE so passionate about giving PLD's Critical Hit Rate on their gear?

[Nutz]

Probably because there are only 5 secondary stats and every piece of gear has 2? You don't want more than capped accuracy and skillspeed is really lackluster since it affects GCD and nothing else. Really, what else would you want? Just double DET on everything or loads of nearly useless parry?

[SeraviEdalborez]

Say that after doing T7 and T8 on PLD. SS is the worst DPS stat by far for PLD, just because of how draining 123 is without any means to get TP back other than Paeon or Shield Swiping.

Don't see the problem. In lieu of Paeon you can spam Stoneskin on yourself a few times in T7 (especially when you have Voice on you). In T8 you shouldn't especially have TP issues once brainjack phase starts.

I have a 2.40 GCD due to my Ruby accessories, technically faster since our SCH uses Selene, and my TP is "fine". I only take the aformentioned Stoneskin TP to ease time for healers and make sure I don't run out of TP mid-FoF.

[LionKing]

SS is the worst stats for all class, not just Paladin, even for MNK.

Back to the topic: Because War is SE beloved child.

P/S: Nothing wrong with having more Crit than Parry. I personally prefer to balance out between Parry and Crit for good defence and good DPS

[Exstal]

SS is the worst stats for all class, not just Paladin, even for MNK.

Back to the topic: Because War is SE beloved child.

P/S: Nothing wrong with having more Crit than Parry. I personally prefer to balance out between Parry and Crit for good defence and good DPS

Skill speed is the same importance as Crit on MNK.

Nope, the more SS you have, the more struggle with TP you have in a long fight. Take T8 for example. I take SS as granted, never one it is one of my priority when it comes to gearing. The order should be Acc>Det>Crit>SS for MNK.

No, I am right. Your example is quite literally the only place in the game where Skill speed is not on par with crit because there are no breaks to recover TP. Since they are the same weight, I gear Acc > Det > crit=ss (whichever is higher)

[LionKing]

Nope, the more SS you have, the more struggle with TP you have in a long fight. Take T8 for example. I take SS as granted, never one it is one of my priority when it comes to gearing. The order should be Acc>Det>Crit>SS for MNK.

[Mijin]

Say that after doing T7 and T8 on PLD. SS is the worst DPS stat by far for PLD, just because of how draining 123 is without any means to get TP back other than Paeon or Shield Swiping.

Ehhhh I have done T7 and T8 on PLD, and I have no idea what type of connection you're trying to make there. While doing neither did I think to myself, "wow, I sure wish I had more crit!" PLD isn't a DPS. The SS is for using defensive/threat generating skills faster -_-; I didn't sing praises about how wonderful SS is either, I just said it's better than CRIT for a PLD, but so is almost everything... To be honest if you run out of TP you're doing it wrong, there is only so much thread that you need to generate, and there are a lot of other things you can do between rotations, put some stoneskins on your self for example, and take comfort in the fact that SS reduces the cool down of other skills besides 123. Even if you use all the CRIT that the game currently allows in gear for PLD, your damage will still be negligible... Use common sense.

[SpookyGhost]

snip

Few things:

1.) As a tank, both WAR and PLD, your main focus should be to survive. However once you reach the HP threshold for the content and have assured your survivability, DPS should be your 2nd highest priority. Whether you like it or not, your DPS contributes to the overall DPS of the group, so the key to be a good WAR/PLD is maximizing effective health to a point and then using everything else for DPSing.
2.) You gain more DPS from Crit than you do SS. You don't gain any mitigation from SS or from Crit, the only possible mitigation based secondary stats you can get are Parry (which scales like booty among a plethora of other problems) and Spell Speed (which afaik isn't available on any left side gear for PLD). Yes, the gains of any secondary stat are marginal and you can have gear with only Piety as your secondary stat and you will have only a small percent less survivability/damage over the course of the fight. This, however, goes completely against the point of your question - you could replace Crit with anything, so why does it matter that you get Crit? What would you rather have? Would you rather just have gear filled with Parry and nothing else? I'd be all for Spell Speed gear if WAR and PLD didn't share 99% of their gear, but as it stands the only things we'll get are Parry, DET and Crit. The only thing you should concentrate on is having as much of your main stats (VIT and STR) as you can get, trading VIT for STR when necessary (ie i90 crafted accessories vs i110 VIT accessories) and reach the accuracy cap for the content you are currently doing. If, one day, they make secondary stats useful then maybe you'll have some weight to your question but as of right now they could give you nothing but Crit on all your gear and it would only make the smallest of difference in your DPS, same with Parry on mitigation, etc. etc.

[Sleigh]

Ehhhh I have done T7 and T8 on PLD, and I have no idea what type of connection you're trying to make there. While doing neither did I think to myself, "wow, I sure wish I had more crit!" PLD isn't a DPS. The SS is for using defensive/threat generating skills faster -_-; I didn't sing praises about how wonderful SS is either, I just said it's better than CRIT for a PLD, but so is almost everything... To be honest if you run out of TP you're doing it wrong, there is only so much thread that you need to generate, and there are a lot of other things you can do between rotations, put some stoneskins on your self for example, and take comfort in the fact that SS reduces the cool down of other skills besides 123. Even if you use all the CRIT that the game currently allows in gear for PLD, your damage will still be negligible... Use common sense.

PLD DPS is not negligible, especially in content where you're not stuck in Shield Oath. That aside ...

http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/1523365/achievement/detail/890/
http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/1523365/achievement/detail/891/
http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodestone/character/1523365/achievement/detail/892/

[Warrlordd]

Whether or not you think your DPS is important or not is not in question. Because it IS important. If your monk could boost his DPS by 10, would you not expect him to? Also, Mijin you contradict yourself when you say that SS is better for using defensive/threat generating skills, and continue to say 'there is only so much threat you need to generate...'

A less experienced tank should realize when he is wrong, and just take the advice from people more experienced than himself.

[Mijin]

PLD DPS is not negligible, especially in content where you're not stuck in Shield Oath. That aside ...

http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodest...nt/detail/890/
http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodest...nt/detail/891/
http://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodest...nt/detail/892/

I appreciate the effort that you're putting into what you think is discrediting me somehow, but unfortunately mapping achievements mean nothing. I took a several month hiatus from the game, and since my return a few weeks ago it is true that I've only been clearing T7 and T8 for a few weeks, but to be honest, the fact that I jumped into the content so quickly and easily after being gone so long also says something of my capabilities. You may not be aware, but the mapping achievements only show that a player has set foot in the entirety of a zone, and T7 and T8 have shortcuts provided the party leader who initiates the content has already made it to the boss in a previous party but failed to clear. When you are joining pugs, at least one out of eight people so very often have the shortcut unlocked for T7 or T8 that I have yet to even set foot in the maps outside of the boss fights there. I also have yet to attempt T7 with the same group as T8, so there is obviously no reason for me to have the mapping achievement, but it's also obvious that this has nothing at all to do with the fact that I have done the content.

Proof that I've at least cleared T7 this week.
Log file proof of T7.

So as you can see, I'm in the exact same place that you are, and if we're to go by your mapping theory, it seems that you've been stuck on T8 for quite some time. It will be interesting to see which one of us finish first.

That being said...T7 and T8 have no barring on the subject of this thread whatsoever, you only brought it up because you mistakenly thought you could prove that I haven't done them, and for some weird reason you thought completing T7 was something worthy of bragging about; it isn't. Since you're trying to assert your self-perceived superiority let me point a few things out.

I mastered this game before you even started playing.
I've cleared much harder content than you.

You would probably retort saying my achievements are worthless, and everything I've done is so easy because I've left you no other rhetorical options, but the difficulty of all content is subjective, and it's kind of pathetic to go around pretending to be superior to other people on the internet. I presume the because of your low self-esteem you're actually seeking affirmation of your self-worth through a video game character, yet you even got shot down in that category; that has to hurt.

Whether or not you think your DPS is important or not is not in question. Because it IS important. If your monk could boost his DPS by 10, would you not expect him to? Also, Mijin you contradict yourself when you say that SS is better for using defensive/threat generating skills, and continue to say 'there is only so much threat you need to generate...'

A less experienced tank should realize when he is wrong, and just take the advice from people more experienced than himself.

Mijin you contradict yourself when you say that SS is better for using defensive/threat generating skills, and continue to say 'there is only so much threat you need to generate...'

using defensive/threat generating skills, and continue to say 'there is only so much threat you need to generate...'

using defensive

contradict yourself

I didn't contradict myself in any way, but it's really ironic that you just did. I was talking about being able to use defensive and threat generating skills faster. The faster you can get your threat capped, the faster you can use defensive skills. I didn't say anything about generating more threat (lol). By your post I can tell you have poor writing skills, so it's also fair to assume that your reading comprehension is probably also low, and as such I can see how you made such a mistake. That was funny though. Oh and I have quite a lot more experience than you, so be more careful with your words.

While the lesser DMG that tanks do may be considered important sometimes when the fight is a DPS race, the amount of DPS that CRIT will add to PLD is negligible. With all of the CRIT anyone can equip on PLD, the resulting increase in DMG is small. Regardless, in reference to your MNK comment, PLD isn't a DPS, defense should pretty much ALWAYS be a PLD's first priority. If you honestly feel you need more DPS in a particular fight go warrior.

Parry and SS are pretty negligible too, but the last thing PLD needs is CRIT (lmao). The concept is so absurd that the only place people who don't know what their talking about would actually argue about it is here. I could make a post on these forums about why rape is a bad thing, and I would get bombarded with statements defending rape, and explaining why it's good, and how I haven't even tried it. You guys are ridiculous, I love these forums.

Few things:

1.) As a tank, both WAR and PLD, your main focus should be to survive. However once you reach the HP threshold for the content and have assured your survivability, DPS should be your 2nd highest priority.

I'm gonna stop you right there. Parry and SS, regardless of how little, increase your ability to survive, which as you yourself mention is the first priority.

Come on guys. Seriously.