I'd be fine with it if it was 100% in my control or 100% my performance that is relied on but the fact is I have to pray that my team members are good players and can win or ultimately the game is still lost.
If it was one player VS one player I'd lose a whole lot less often so it's kind of BS to have it there as my performance when it's not even my performance alone it's a team activity.
I don't have a PVP team to play with so I am forced to play with randoms to do my PVP, half the time the groups are bad.
It would be even worse if others could see it, you could Que in with randoms and get in unlucky groups all day and people would just think your a bad player because you have lots of loses.
Commendations are the one and only thing that should be seen by others and recorded.