Is 1.18 the final straw?

[Mack]

Personally being a old school FF fan and growing up on FFIV, id say FF XII and FF XIII are absolute gaming diarrhea.

Then I enjoy diarrhea quite a bit...in fact I take colonoscopy pills just to get my bowel movements rollings because I love diarrhea that much.

[Bled]

Then I enjoy diarrhea quite a bit...in fact I take colonoscopy pills just to get my bowel movements rollings because I love diarrhea that much.

Like i stated my opinion and only the correlation i have seen, keep in mind there is always an outlier in any data set. However if you enjoy diarrhea more power to you, if you like Colonoscopy you should look into Sigmoidoscopy too.

[Mack]

Lol Its all good I didn't mean anything by what I said, I understand people like different games but to me personally I joined the FF roller coaster at FFX and absolutely loved it and FFXIV is the first game in the series since then (including VII, VIII and IX) that I've had ill feelings towards. I don't think SE is slipping here, I do think however that they need to stop expanding horizontally and start expanding vertically...instead of working on a 100 projects at a time, work on a few and make them amazing.

[SuzakuCMX]

FFXII was praised by almost every single gaming source >.> Just an FYI.

[Bled]

Lol Its all good I didn't mean anything by what I said, I understand people like different games but to me personally I joined the FF roller coaster at FFX and absolutely loved it and FFXIV is the first game in the series since then (including VII, VIII and IX) that I've had ill feelings towards. I don't think SE is slipping here, I do think however that they need to stop expanding horizontally and start expanding vertically...instead of working on a 100 projects at a time, work on a few and make them amazing.

Yeah it would be nice to see another AAA Final Fantasy title, but again it all comes down to the fact that people enjoy different games like you all ready stated.

[Bled]

FFXII was praised by almost every single gaming source >.> Just an FYI.

IGN praised it, then did a top FF title and put it at #7, so what does that tell you of gaming sources... O.o

[SuzakuCMX]

IGN praised it, then did a top FF title and put it at #7, so what does that tell you of gaming sources...

It tells me that there are better Final Fantasies, but FFXII was still better than about half of them?

[Mack]

IGN praised it, then did a top FF title and put it at #7, so what does that tell you of gaming sources... O.o

Actually with all due respect, with regards to FFXII I think the fans said it all (gamespot alone): http://www.gamespot.com/ps2/rpg/fina...lt%3Btitle%3B0

21,989 votes averaged the game at 9.1/10...that makes it a success.

Not to mention 73 critics averaged it at 9.1 too.

[Physic]

IGN praised it, then did a top FF title and put it at #7, so what does that tell you of gaming sources... O.o

It tells you that being an FF is stiff competition gamewise. FXII was pretty good, if this game had half the content of fxii it would be getting praised for content.
Im not saying its the best FF ever, but really it was pretty big, had marks, summon battles, hidden in far off dungeons, a pretty large world, enemies that interacted with each other. epic fights, a ton of bosses, i think if this game had that stuff, no one would be complaining about it.

[Bled]

It tells me that there are better Final Fantasies, but FFXII was still better than about half of them?

yet it still dose not detract from it being a poor FF title in my eyes, that's 6 other FF's id rather play..