If only we had some kind of megathread for this topic...
Printable View
Why isn't this in the Megathread, OP?
The cool thing is posting in the megathread and making a smaller thread aren't mutually exclusive and help make more noise on an issue, if you don't want to read the thread don't click on it.
You clearly have no idea what you're talking about, the server isn't constantly checking files as you play, it won't crash your game if things don't match up, things crash if something just flat out doesn't work and stops the game from working. And none of that changes that the hairs seem to work fine as is on Viera most of the time, some ear clipping or whatnot is not an issue.
I'm not wholly sure how locking an entire race out of using optional hairstyles (some of which are only obtainable via the FFXIV Store...for cash) is SE being "greedy".
Like, fundamentally, they want the races to have access to all the hair, because you're more likely to spend money on the cash shop if you have access to all the hair on your character. The more you like your character, the more likely you are to spend money on them.
Is defnitely not clipping issues... The new hair head top is pretty flat, the ear models would have no problem popping out from them.
In fact, I don't think there is any style, other than that delinquent pompadour or the Sahz's one that would have anything clipping through ears that start on the top of the head.
Yeah, for sure. A vague comment in response to a question an interviewer happened to ask almost 2 years later isn't exactly the type of transparency we are looking for on this matter.
I don't agree with you on the initial topic. We aren't a community of children. The very game addresses matters of genocide and murder, two of the most heavy actions that can occur in our reality. The lion's share of us aren't going to crumble at the mere mention of a word being used to the point of not even being able to assess its context. Also, I did not say that SE or Yoshi P are racist in general as if it's some sort of status aliment a person or entity can be afflicted with. I am being literal that the action is racist against the race of Viera in regard to excluding them for content every other race (minus Hroth) are getting for their hair continuously for two years now. Even for hairs made post their release.
Ultimately, context to words matter when assessing their meaning and that applies equally even to words such as racism. The people of this community are more than mentally capable of making such distinctions. Those complaining and being upset have shown failure on their part to reasonably assess the accurate use of my word use and I would go as far to say that such people are even being overly sensitive in regard to its usage. Thus, I find the fault on them rather than on myself, as the usage of my word is correct in context. I don't even think it's a matter of politics in that regard.
And yes, other than that I am in full agreement. It's to the issue's benefit to have this topic discussed with a new thread each time it arises. And, since it is often brought up, I also think it's great to talk about it in the megathread. Both together will help maximize awareness of the issue. I suppose one could go even a step forward and email Square about it as well. All of which has my support. Differences of opinion on various other things aside, I think it's good that we can come together on this issue finally being addressed and talked about from the FFXIV team. It's something worth continually pushing for until a real plan to address it is talked about and comes to fruition. It's more than reasonable, especially at this point in time.
I'm not "trying," I am correctly stating what it is. To continuously exclude the Viera race of hairstyles when all the other races in the game get them is literally an instance of racist action. It's not nearly as unfair as if it was racism towards the races of real people, obviously, but no one has stated that. So, no, it's not an overexaggeration. You are just being overly sensitive to the word because you are caught up in the sensationalism around the term and desperately want to defend Square. It is a correct usage of the word racist to describe an act of exclusion targeted towards a race in a game though.
What are you even saying? There is no difference between what file structure the vanilla game uses vs. a modded game. The files are merely swapped out when you mod. The vanilla models being updated merely changes what those vanilla models are. Are you trying to imply that if a hair is out of place it's going to cause the game to crash? It might cause a bit of clipping, but no, what you describe isn't even somewhat sensible in the slightest. You literally just proved to anyone with any know how of the game that you are the one who has no idea what you are talking about, but that you are pretending that you do because you are just that much of a brownnose. Thanks for proving that point further for me.
Japanese companies outsource, what are you talking about? I don't understand this mindset of just making things up to desperately defend a corporation of all things.
Conclusion? No, I can complain as much as I want, as can anyone else, so long as we do so within the forum rules. You're just going to have to deal with it. If anything, you are the one who isn't at all being constructive and literally just making things up to desperately to defend a corp. I can't believe you actually thought that would accomplish anything.
Because it isn't just locking people out of hairstyles. It's avoiding putting the effort, resources and time into creating a plan, allocating budget, or seeking an outsource option (if necessary) to accomplish the goal. There's an obvious benefit, of course, to doing it, but they clearly didn't want to invest what was necessary to accomplish it, else it would have been completed within a 2 year window. They clearly didn't think the return was worth it and that it was more worthwhile to shaft those who are drawn to play the race of Viera. Us who complain and are disgruntled by their choice is the fallout from that.
You mean a lack of an address for nearly 2 years with no actual discussion or communication, not even at fanfest, and having to re-experience it with every new hair that is released? The words aren't too strong, nor too weak, but accurate. Viera are a game race, to exclude them as a race is racist in context to content exclusion, thus I use the word racist to describe the action of doing so because it's correct to do so, which is plain to see in the full context of my posts. It's not my problem if some people lose all composure and sense at the word because of being too caught up in sensationalism around the adjective (or just purposely attempting to derail and fish for clout...). Context matters, and that you have to remove context from my posts to try to make a faulty point tells me that you have no intention of having legitimate discussion of the actual topic of the thread. Which, if that's the case, make your own topic, by all means.
i am going to speculate we will never get new hairstyles .. maybe 1 or 2 over the upcoming 2-3 years , why? because as someone said (jokingly) which now i believe to be true they don't want Viera to become the most popular race now with male Viera added ,. why ? because when someone google ffxiv the first thing they see are pictures of miqos and lalafells so they are the face of ffxiv? viera were suppose to be a fan requested race only .
if you say lalafells are not that popular in the west they are extremely popular on Japanese servers .
I mean with them working on male viera and hrothgals? You ain't likely seeing new hairs for a while for either since they already stressed that just doing male viera was only by working super hard as is, and once they are out they will likely be using any extra time to then work on the hrothgals.
So yeah.
Can't say anything to the racist argument. Just let me say that I've seen pics with the new hairstyle on viera (mods of course) and I don't get why they aren't getting that style. It's pretty, it doesn't clip, I just fucking love it.
Hurry up SE. May you destroy our dreams but give us a statement. Are we forced in only the starter styles?
Okay first of all to be clear I myself play on ps4 only. I stopped playing Viera because it was kinda frustrating not to be able to use the hair drops I got.
I know someone on pc and they have their bunny modded and any of the hair works just fine, and many of the hats. (Yeah I know this isn't allowed but it's not my account)
Why doesn't this company allow the submission of mods for approval, or for use by the company themselves. It would cut out a lot of work for SE and the community could also get involved.
I'm not expecting anything, but it's not like you can stop people from making threads you don't like so you're just gonna have to deal with it or ignore it.
Besides, it's the General Discussion forums, we're not exactly scribbling on the Dead Sea scrolls here. It's really not that deep.
It's not really nitpicking, the reason why people keep arguing about it is because the OP refuses to back down from something that people think is pretty obvious.
I think that if you showed the comments about it being racism to pretty much anyone they'd have a very negative reaction to it and think that it's a crazy accusation.
No one is saying that you can't criticize the devs either, in this very thread there are people criticizing both the OP for throwing the term '' racism '' around so wildly AND criticizing the devs for the hairstyle situation.
I am pretty sure that if you went up to Yoshida and accused him of being racist he'd have a negative reaction to it too and take it personally.
Because it is a personal attack and accusation.
That's not tone policing either, no one is criticizing the OP for being emotional people are criticizing the OP for that term being used.
If the OP had just not used that but been upset it wouldn't be a problem.
Posting a fancy screenshot you found with a nice buzzword is also a convenient way to not have to adress peoples actual problems and criticism.
Edit: Maybe some people are criticizing the OP for being emotional, but not the person you accused of tone policing.
Have they even said that the Male Viera hair won't be usable on Female Viera?
I mean Male Viera had very similar looking hair in the trailer it wouldn't even surprise me if they end up sharing hair and that's how they add more.
https://i.ytimg.com/vi/6NxPJ_BPSwU/maxresdefault.jpg
This is some real facts and logics right here, you're a real internet debater.
Respect.
You're right, it isn't nitpicking quite as much as it's bad faith clout fishing (if not veiled attempts to derail) and/or oversensitivity to the accurate usage of language. It is content exclusion specifically for an in-game race, thus it is racist content exclusion. Trying to twist that into me saying they are racist in general is malicious and a deliberate misreading of the context of what I said. I will not pretend it is something it isn't just because you think the term should only ever be used in reference to the real world races of actual people. Language is contextual, and so you must read it in regard to its contextual use, not clutch your pearls and ignore the context because you want to be self righteous or what not.
Theorizing that female Viera will get a bunch of male hairs isn't some sort of solution to what we are generally complaining about which is a lack of communication for almost two years now. And, really, what most of us want, and rightfully so, is Viera versions of all item add-on hair to be made and there have been numerous posts explaining why that is more than reasonable to be done. But, I digress as the matter of male Viera hair being added to female Viera or not is really besides the point to begin with as explained.
Amnmaat didn't say he can guarantee anything. That is a blatant misreading of what he said and thus a strawman. He said he can give an "almost guarantee," which expresses nothing but strong belief. That you think this is "real facts and logics" or the words of a "real internet debater" is really just adding evidence of you finding appeal in faulty argumentation and bad faith social engagement. When you actually correctly read what he said, he made no claims of guarantees, but instead expressed strong belief that there would be hairs added by 6.1. In which, that's nothing really to criticize. I personally do not share in his belief given how these last 2 years were like in regard to the matter, but I also understand some people like to be rather optimistic. Regardless, I find the aggression and ill tactics aimed at him to be in poor taste and even poorer ethics.
Oh sweetie... I even grabbed his previous comments for your reading pleasure and, also, according to the dictionary:
- To guarantee is to promise with certainty and
- A belief is an acceptance that something exists or is true, especially one without proof.
So we get two different concepts here; better pick one that better suits your rationale right? I'm not discussing semantics with you any further.
If someone is coming here to guarantee whatever, better be prepared to back up the claim as a normal person does.
Let us be real it probably came down to new hair styles for females or the male counter part. We saw the one they choose. Now the question remains will you guys have to wait until female hrogth are added before you hair?
The first post of his isn't the one you quoted in your reply to him. The second one was, which is his latest post on the matter, in which he clarifies it's an "almost guarantee." You can't in good faith exclude the modifier of a word to single out that word to make your point as that is misrepresenting what the person says. It's literally deception and misrepresentation. It's not even a question of semantics. That's like going to someone who says, "I hardly miss him," removing the hardly modifier, and acting if the person said they missed him. It completely changes what the person conveyed. Just like here, an almost guarantee means he can't quite guarantee it, but it's so likely in his belief that he can almost guarantee it. The word almost is not some meaningless word that you can just toss out because it's convientant for you to do so to respond harshly to him. If you are posting in good faith, I'm sure you can understand that.
This. I think what many ppl don't realize is that even though SE is a multi-million dollar company, their resources are not infinite and while XIV is a profitable game, there are a lot of other, more important, pieces of this game as well as other games they need to put not only money but also development toward.
Is it crappy that they cannot deliver more hair styles? yes. Is it the end of the world that is costing them subs? Maybe a handful, but not likely even a remotely noticeable amount. They likely had to make a choice, and they chose to appease the ppl who have the 2 year old, thousands of replies long thread about wanting male viera over those who just want new hair. And they chose reasonably.
Multi-billion, to put it more accurately. While their resources are not infinite, the idea that they couldn't afford to hire temporary staff or outsource the task of merely adjusting hairs to fit the Viera head, something many hairs would need very little to be able to do which can be seen through the efforts of modders, seems rather preposterous to me. The idea that it was an either or scenario in regard to how much money they could afford to spend seems very unrealistic to me. Especially over a two year window, in which, this issue too has had constant feedback over from the beginning, just like male Viera. One or the other being personally more important to you doesn't change that for many others, their cares are with the female Viera's lack of hair and headgear support. And beyond that, and this does matter quite a bit, the lack of communication about it all speaks volumes to those who have taken up issue with it, especially given the amount of time and missed opportunities for Square to do otherwise. It's frustration and fuss that is more than well deserved at this point, and it will not cease until a resolution is met. Rather, it will only increase in time, and fairly so.
The only reason a mega thread wasn't started over this much sooner was because, as far as we knew, they didn't need convincing or coaxing to actually do it. They had already consented to adding hairstyles and faces/manes before the expansion even came out, so we had no reason to not believe they wouldn't at the time, or that it'd take this long. Because that'd be crazy right? Almost two years with not a single hairstyle added?
I'm not gonna say they choose poorly because in the end that's their decision to make, but like Yandere said, I find it hard to believe they had 0 resources in all this time to even adapt a single hairstyle or give a less vague update than "please wait a bit longer".
Because hairstyles aren't important right now. You think hairstyles take precedence over actual content? Endwalker is a lot bigger than ShadowBringers. Alongside the strict schedule they follow for patches/updates and with Covid-19 impacting their production you seriously think hairstyles are more important and should be top priority? You get it when you get it. I'm still waiting for my female Hrothgar which I'm glad is coming. But I'm not sitting here slandering SE like OP.
seems like you are just asking to get this thread closed or just banned.
FFXIV is a product. They make things to make money. Viera wasn't a gift. It was an extension to their product to encourage the continued subscription and use of that product. That product extension is being racially excluded of features other similar product inclusions possess. This has been the state of being for a period of about two years now with essentially no communication to us about it, which is unacceptable for many customers that extension is relevant to. Square Enix isn't your dad. It's a corporation that exists to elicit profit from customers. This forum exists in part for the purpose of customers complaining about the product they have paid / are paying for. If you don't like that, you don't have to participate, but we use the forum for its intended purpose regardless. With all due respect, try not to throw rocks from a glass house in regard to having a "crappy attitude."