Yeah, that's not a very reasonable stance. Weaponskills should be balanced for their level, but it's simply not reasonable to expect all of your weaponskills to be useful for all the levels. How are you going to balance Double Thrust against Penta Thrust? Full Break vs. Armor/Weapon/Shield Break? Keen Edge vs. Raging Rush?

That said, it would be nice if SE could balance weaponskills across jobs. Then Dark Knights wouldn't end up using Great Axe for the first 50+ levels, Thieves wouldn't end up using Sword or H2H for the first 32-34 levels, Dancer wouldn't end up using Sword or H2H for the first 50+ levels, etc.