Treasure Hunter Effect Amongst Jobs

[Zinato]

It just seems that procs are more important to yield than TH.

This is a fact, not a theory. In 2 hours of kill farming (skipping procs in favor of killing speed) with TH3 I came out of Glacier with 15 shells, 4 forgotten. Over 100 kill and all yagudo, with a stray proc here and there from weaponskill, were it not for those procs I would have gotten ~4 shells. If someone wants to address conjestion and competition in Dynamis the Proc system is what needs to be address.

Also, how did the TH thread get back to Dynamis talk? Once again, Proc = Currency, BST/DNC is the most effective at procing (not TH), If BST loses TH it will not change how many enter Dynamis. What it will change is how fast they kill (Since they will need more mobs and proc to make up the difference, so they will use a stronger pet. and BTW, this is only making things worse for BST haters) and How many total times they will enter dynamis to be your competition.

[Glamdring]

This is a fact, not a theory. In 2 hours of kill farming (skipping procs in favor of killing speed) with TH3 I came out of Glacier with 15 shells, 4 forgotten. Over 100 kill and all yagudo, with a stray proc here and there from weaponskill, were it not for those procs I would have gotten ~4 shells. If someone wants to address conjestion and competition in Dynamis the Proc system is what needs to be address.

Also, how did the TH thread get back to Dynamis talk? Once again, Proc = Currency, BST/DNC is the most effective at procing (not TH), If BST loses TH it will not change how many enter Dynamis. What it will change is how fast they kill (Since they will need more mobs and proc to make up the difference, so they will use a stronger pet. and BTW, this is only making things worse for BST haters) and How many total times they will enter dynamis to be your competition.

I was actually pointing out that many other jobs can solo dynamis effectively, and that it's procs, not TH that they need to address when they decide to solo. I just think that-protestations to the contrary-it's the the large numbers of beast soloers in there that's driving the nerf of pet TH, not some worry about "fairness". The fix for TH is-I still maintain-the need to make yields actually go up SIGNIFIGANTLY with each Tier increase, not to do away with the TH. THAT would fix the lack of desire for thieves, too; nerfing beast pets will have no effect on the current state of thief.