Originally Posted by
JakzChurchill
My exact quote was "but then you'll have a gun... and never use it to complete your role". The complete your role portion is key in this subject. With both Scholar and White mage you draw magic from your weapon which you then channel into a spell. When healing your are using the magical properties or the weapons to complete your task. A gun would be different, as it's sole purpose is too deal damage, you wouldn't be using the gun itself to complete the healing part of your role. therefore it is not being used to it's full effectiveness where it could be with some other classes.
Saying that the gun shields could be an interesting choice for a tank weapon, but I don't what class would be created for them. I am totally behind Samurai as a tank, but I would hope any great sword class (dark knight please) is a dps job, else it would end up playing too close to warrior as a tank, something an agile samurai can get away from.
If the first paragraph came off a bit strong I apologise, it is meant purely to emphasise my point in greater detail and not intended as argumentative.