dagger ws too OP?

[Afania]

But by your own arguments earlier, WAR shouldn't be buffed, because they have warcry, and that brings something beneficial to the party, so therefore they shouldn't be doing significant amounts of dmg.

The real question is, does war cry make up the gap between WAR and SAM? Yes? Invite the WAR. No? No invite for WAR.

Also, lol at BLU being 2nd tier.

BLU was definitely 2nd tier before CDC update, behind SAM, which was the 1st tier. Not sure why'd it need that much dmg when it can already do a lot more than just dmg.

At the top end of the spectrum, with nice gear and nice buffs, SAM still beats THF and the difference is not huge. Effective use of skillchains and SA+TA can make THF the best DD in the game, poor use of skillchains or SA/TA will cause it to lag behind other equally geared DD. I see nothing wrong with this

It is wrong because THF already guarantee a pt slot, while certain jobs don't.

I have WAR and SAM leveled and geared and it's my call which I come as. My friend has DRK and was never turned away when a DD was needed either. Is SAM better? Sure. Is WAR plenty good for anything that needs a DD? It is. The same couldn't be said for the 1-hander DDs before the update and some of them still don't have a spot even now.

Personal experience, that has nothing to do with job balance. I've joined incursion/delve pt on BLU before the update, my THF friend have joined delve/incursion pt before the update. We still do more dmg than 95% of PUG SAM.

If you want to use personal experience such as "I got invite np, thus I don't care if THF DNC is competing for the pt slot", I can do the same....I got invite np before the update, thus BLU and THF were just fine.

Yeah you really don't understand. I don't want the DDs to be tiered at all. I don't want it to matter one bit which melee job one brings. I want my WAR and someone else's THF to be on the same level without either of us being dragged downward.

If THF can do exactly the same dmg as WAR, I'd just invite a THF instead of WAR to incursion and delve. More airlixir without sacrificing the kill speed, why not.

You're the one that really don't understand, unless SE disable TH, it's simply not possible to accomplish true job balance. We're still going to pick DDs, in this case we're going to pick a DD that can do top dmg AND give more drops.