Un-gimping magic procs in dynamis

[Kristal]

What job would you say is better?

PUP. The same mechanism that is a bane in Abyssea is a boon in Dynamis.

And how does that change anything in his post?

It's mostly complaining about certain job/subjob combinations that already have a distinct advantage are not good at everything.

Noone is good on magic procs, not even RDM, although the math shows that you actually need slightly less then twice the proc attempts to get a proc compared to WS and JA.

[FrankReynolds]

PUP. The same mechanism that is a bane in Abyssea is a boon in Dynamis.


It's mostly complaining about certain job/subjob combinations that already have a distinct advantage are not good at everything.

Noone is good on magic procs, not even RDM, although the math shows that you actually need slightly less then twice the proc attempts to get a proc compared to WS and JA.

So now that pup is the best at WS procs, how does that fix anything?

[hiko]

So now that pup is the best at WS procs, how does that fix anything?

now we know

procing 1/5 mobs with WS (at best)
/.../
would take 4-5 runs of dynamis in WS time to get as many coins as one run in JA time.

is total bullshit and that WS mob can be a decent alternative over highcamped JA mobs.

If you talk about post subject (ie magic proc ) nothing, we have
JA best proc
WS inferior to JA but still able to get a nice amount of currencies
MA bad need to be fixed

[Lisotte]

now we know is total bullshit and that WS mob can be a decent alternative over highcamped JA mobs.

If you talk about post subject (ie magic proc ) nothing, we have
JA best proc
WS inferior to JA but still able to get a nice amount of currencies
MA bad need to be fixed

Pretty much this. As a PUP I usually expect to make around ~130 coins out of a decent run (I'm looking to make more when I get some better gear). BST friends of mine make 150-250 coins. Mage friends... don't do dyna.