Mastercrafts Consumables Pls Nerf

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Teah_Kaye

But you only have to overmeld your crafting gear like 2-3 times an expansion? Definitely not weekly. And you don't even need to penta all of it, you can craft your HQ gear and consumables with budget melds just fine.

---

Yeah I can do budget melds. But then I have to craft even more of the pieces used in the craft as HQ. Which increases the amount I'm spent crafting on the weekly by at least double. Which also sucks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rinalas

I'd be perfectly happy with raids having more sellable loot. If I could just sell the mounts or if orchestrion was savage exclusive or even selling the gear? I'd be fine with that. The crafters who want the higher-end gear but do not raid can buy that from me and I would use that money to buy potions from them. It would "stimulate the market" and create a give and take between these facets that neither group partakes in.

However, I believe that just "make pots and food not have as high of a crafting requirement" would be a much easier change to get going. They can nerf raids and class complexity for battle content, why not crafter content too?

---

Crafting has already been significantly nerfed, though? It used to have an impossibly high barrier of entry, and in recent expansions it has had almost none.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rehayem

Okay, I might sound rude here but... that's a you problem. I don't like doing Deep Dungeons for example, but you don't see me cry at SE to nerf it down because I find it boring and I want the loot from there because I'm lazy.

Making gil in this game is easy as hell, and you can do it just fine with just battle jobs, no crafting needed. My friend hates crafting as well, yet she made bank by selling gemstone materials.

So what exactly do you want? Do you want SE to butcher crafters and gatherers just as they butchered battle jobs? No. Either git gud or learn how to make gil in game.

---

You can live without Deep Dungeon Loot. You not having deep dungeon loot doesn't affect your ability to play the content you enjoy. Me not engaging in more lucrative content does significant affect my ability to enjoy raiding. You see how your analogy does not hold up?

And yeah, maybe they should nerf crafters like they nerfed battle jobs. That's obviously the perfect solution. [/s] At least then there'd be some justice in this game. Make every single thing easy peasy just like the casuals wanted to begin with. Then no one can be happy.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rinalas

Make every single thing easy peasy just like the casuals wanted to begin with. Then no one can be happy.

---

Yet here you are asking for this lol

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkyrie-Veil

Crafting has already been significantly nerfed, though? It used to have an impossibly high barrier of entry, and in recent expansions it has had almost none.

---

Don't get me wrong, I'm as thrilled as the next person that Maker's Mark got axed. That's great.
In a perfect world, they would leave crafting as-is so everyone who likes it can enjoy it, and raiding wouldn't be forced to rely on crafting for those who hate it. Like the Firmament was great. I loved the Firmament. I wasn't a crafter but it was crafting content they could have that didn't stick it's nose in my content. Crafters could enjoy that without it affecting me at all. But unfortunately, this system is what they've started with and change must be boiled slowly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Masekase_Hurricane

Yet here you are asking for this lol

---

It fascinates me that your entire enjoyment on FFXIV is apparently just the inconvenience others if you believe me being able to make my own consumables by myself within a reasonable amount of time each week is really the be-all and end-all of your enjoyment of the game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rinalas

It fascinates me that your entire enjoyment on FFXIV is apparently just the inconvenience others if you believe me being able to make my own consumables by myself within a reasonable amount of time each week is really the be-all and end-all of your enjoyment of the game.

---

That’s the thing consumables are a market that people profit off of specifically because people like you don’t like crafting

Nerfing the consumable requirements and materials directly affects their market and has downstream effects on reducing the incentive to level your own crafters which also affects the gear and materia markets

This isn’t just “we hate you so continue to suffer”, you aren’t thinking about the implications of this

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Somnolence

It would be very naive to assume these big stacks on MB are crafted without plugin assistance.

Everybody defending this system are either useful idiots or on-it.

---

It doesn't help that anyone defending the system here doesn't have anything intellectual to bring to a discussion beyond "Nuh-uh!" or "But what will I do to have fun if you aren't being bored for 8 hours each week?? :'("

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rinalas

It fascinates me that your entire enjoyment on FFXIV is apparently just the inconvenience others if you believe me being able to make my own consumables by myself within a reasonable amount of time each week is really the be-all and end-all of your enjoyment of the game.

---

So maybe come up with a better solution than lower recipe difficulty i.e craft 10 at a time? Both sides happy and no crappy rants...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Supersnow845

That’s the thing consumables are a market that people profit off of specifically because people like you don’t like crafting

Nerfing the consumable requirements and materials directly affects their market and has downstream effects on reducing the incentive to level your own crafters which also affects the gear and materia markets

This isn’t just “we hate you so continue to suffer”, you aren’t thinking about the implications of this

---

I recognize that it's a market that uses currency. And people make this currency off of selling it to people who don't want to waste their time with it. However, what do they need this currency for, anyways? The game doesn't even have that many gil sinks. Almost every single thing you use gil for is made from crafting anyways which crafters could just make and thus won't need to buy. You can't possibly argue they need all that for teleport fees or their one-time house purchase.