I think Enmity is fine.

This game would be boring if all anyone had to do was bring a paladin and turn everything into a tank an spank dps race. Part of what makes this game more fun than other MMORPGs I have played is there is actually some strategy involved and other party members actually become targets.

I think the real problem with Paladins is our most effective job ability for protecting party members who generate a lot of enmity - cover - is horribly designed. Trying to use it is a pain in the @$$. It should be like on other Final Fantasy games where it causes the Paladin to automatically leap in front of the member you are trying to protect or at the very least transfer the damage directly. Because making it a positional ability requires too much hassle and just isn't realistic.

I also think paladin gear should have a lot more -spell interruption on it so it could play it's role as a heal/tank more effectively.