While I definitely appreciate a response to this thread that is significantly more coherent than Zeitzone's, I'm afraid I'll have to refute a couple of your points:
Counter 1: Even before the release of Abyssea, players were partying in 4 zones total, leaving 95% of them empty. People would solo to 18~ish (or use the Dunes if they were masochists), go to Qufim, then East Ronfaure [S], then Wajaom and Bhaflau to 75. Even before the release of WotG (which was years ago now), players generally only used 4-5 zones for exp'ing. Players have long since identified the most easily accessible and efficient camps in the game. While alternative options do exist (and had to for reasons I will elaborate on in Counter 6), they were as underused as Overworld exp areas are now. Removing Abyssea's EXP options while keeping WotG and ToAU in play will not increase the diversity in leveling locations at all. If anything, you'll be leveling in fewer zones since Abyssea utilizes between 4-7 zones on its own depending on your server (Scars + Heroes + La Theine).
Counter 2: The thing is, low level armor has practically no impact on playing jobs and hasn't in ages. Even if Abyssea were nerfed, people would still only exp in 4 general level ranges; 20~ > 30~ > 55~ > 75. If anything, people would be unable to find armor for their level because there is no profit in crafting it. The majority of the old armor on the Auction House wasn't newly forged, it was armor that people used and then resold. Now, most of this armor is out of the system, either because it's been tossed due to an inability to sell, or it's on a deactivated mule somewhere. As a Smith, I could run around making Solid Mail pieces, but why would I? I take a loss with every synth, even if I HQ, and it's generally a waste of my time.
Counter 3: Abyssea also drops a significantly wider variety of crafting materials than any exp camp in the game. Colibri Feathers and Colibri Beaks aren't used for something important now, are they? Once a player hits level 34~, those are the only crafting mats they'll be getting aside from Wind Crystals. In Abyssea, you can pick up buffalo and dragon meat, essential ingredients in popular foods, as well as high level synthesis mats like Divine Logs and Siren's Hairs. Abyssea promotes crafting on a very large scale.
Counter 4: The game's economy has shifted, but it's hard to say that it is not thriving. In the past, the majority of the best gear in the game required millions of gil to purchase on the AH, or merc for R/EX gear if you weren't in an HNM shell. Whoever could buy enough gil could get a relic and +1 gears. I'm not saying getting Gil was difficult, but there were definitely a choice few who cheated that system. Now, getting the best gear in the game requires going out and actually fighting things. You can't buy a Tantra Cyclas +2 off the AH. You have to go out and kill Gamayun and Alfard a dozen times each if you want one. Granted, you can still pay people to do these things for you, but as a general statement, the amount of Gil in your bank account no longer limits your ability to gear yourself properly.
Items like Grim Cuirass, Alcide's Harness, Hermes' Sandals, Juogis, and Spells of all classes also still sell well on the AH. Consumables like Shihei, and food, are never short on demand. Crafting took a hit with the reduced (read: little to none) demand for mid-level armor like Haubergeons, but at the same time the materials for those armors and higher level pieces became extremely cheap and easy to find because of Abyssea. Demand fell, but so did costs. Fishermen can still pull in millions a week as well, so it's hard to say crafting is entirely dead; or if it is, that Abyssea could fix it.
Counter 5: This is a false comparison. It only takes maybe a day to skill up multiple weapons to cap (which you can do afk on Zvhal Fortalices), and about that much time to skill magics to cap on Hpemde. Unless it actually takes 2-3 days to level 30-90 with all weapons capped (and noting that no WAR in his right mind would use a Scythe in an EXP party, I would kick them so fast) the normal way, leveling in Abyssea and then skilling up afterwards is still significantly faster.
Counter 6: This is the only real argument of any validity I've been hearing. Unfortunately, it relies on one very important premise. If low level players are unable to find parties because no one is exp'ing at low level ranges, then it cannot also be true that there are a large number of players who want to exp at these low level ranges. Now, that's fine, if players who are against Abyssea are a minority then yes this is a problem. Low level players do not have the Cruor or the game experience to create their own Abyssea parties and/or leech in them. It is difficult for a lone new player to get very far on their own. With a social linkshell, however, even new players should be able to find people willing to level sync with them.
Addendum to 6: Also, if Abyssea were removed as a leveling area, one of the biggest faults with FFXI exp would come back into play. That is to say, camp crowding. The best exp camps in the game can only afford 1-2 good parties at a time, maybe 3 if some of the parties are less than stellar. Bhaflau Birds (MMJ and NI RPs) were notorious for this, and often times merit parties would be cancelled entirely despite a solid setup due to a lack of space during prime times. For what good it did to break up leveling into multiple ranges, *fewer* people were able to level at any given time then than do now. Abyssea allowing 18 people in a single party, and having camps whose mob respawns adjust themselves to the rate at which they are being killed constitute the biggest step forward in FFXI EXP history.
I will have my revenge!
Please read my above post as to why this is a misconception.
Pre-level sync my only 75 was DRK. After sync I leveled DRG and WAR to 75 and never did I have to abuse Colibri or Qufim camps. We exp'd like we did pre-level sync, the only difference was the 2-3 level gaps that many parties experienced that reduced exp was now gone and everyone who was 60-65 could get equal exp in Aydeewa parties instead of having the typical 61-64 level gaps.
RIP Shadowix 75 DRG-WAR-DRK
[QUOTE=Valaris;39847] I would counter with replacing his name with yours. What he says is true. Merit/EXP places in old areas died when ToAU came out; and a lack of great things to EXP on meant that didn't change at WotG's release.
Honestly, the best part of the recent developments is people are less fussy about jobs. You know how hard it was to level up WHM, SMN, PUP, and some of the less popular DD jobs just because of people only wanting to party with BRDs, SAMs, and RDMs? If you wanted to play those jobs, you were lucky if you could party at all, because people would demand only the "best". Since abyssea, that hardly happens at all anymore.
Just because it happened does not mean that it is the norm. The average player only used Colibri burns the majority of the time. Even then, you're adding, what, 4 zones to the mix if we're being generous (Jungle, Kuftal, Aydeewa, QSC)? That still leaves 85-90% of the zones in the game untouched. Some of them weren't used for exp even when us Dinosaurs were leveling.
I will have my revenge!
Player
Lol i bet i did more Endgame as you ever will in the time FFXI has left till its gone.
My gears are pimped out on max dmg but i dont need to pose that, i know my gear is good.
And i prefer a nice slow experience point party becouse it is a fair way to get up, not like leechig.
You guys just dont know the true way of gameing, thats very sad, you allways want to put in the cheat codes by Gothic or Morrowind, and ask friends for Endboss savegames becouse you are too lazy to get the weapons and spells the correct way or get trough the game on own power.
Last edited by Wherffin; 03-21-2011 at 06:57 AM. Reason: This post has been edited due to inappropriate language
Yes, run away because you are "done feeding the trolls" and not because multiple people prove you wrong. At least I admit to trolling, how about you?
Last edited by Emdub; 03-21-2011 at 07:31 AM. Reason: Removed previously deleted comment from quote
|
© SQUARE ENIX FINAL FANTASY, SQUARE ENIX, and the SQUARE ENIX logo are registered trademarks of Square Enix Holdings Co., Ltd. Vana'diel , Tetra Master, PLAYONLINE, the PLAYONLINE logo, Rise of the Zilart, Chains of Promathia, Treasures of Aht Urhgan, and Wings of the Goddess are registered trademarks of Square Enix Co., Ltd. The rating icon is a registered trademark of the Entertainment Software Association. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Online play requires internet connection. |