Battle stances!

I'm surprised that different races don't have different weapon stances like they did in FFXI:

Example of MNK battle stance of different races:
http://www.ffxionline.com/forums/att...mnkstances.gif

PS3 Limitations.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ardan

PS3 Limitations.

---

I don't know if we can blame Sony's system for holding back the game this time. We'd have to know how far Square is pushing the game on the PS3. But yes, I would love to see individual battle stances. I loved the Elvaan animation for casting white magic, black magic and the Dragon Kick weapon skill. But when summoning - he looked he was taking a sh*t. And don't get me started on dancing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brianmj

I don't know if we can blame Sony's system for holding back the game this time. We'd have to know how far Square is pushing the game on the PS3. But yes, I would love to see individual battle stances. I loved the Elvaan animation for casting white magic, black magic and the Dragon Kick weapon skill. But when summoning - he looked he was taking a sh*t. And don't get me started on dancing.

---

But Elvaan male had a wicked great katana stance where as my mithra looked like she was holding a baseball bat.
And also, FFXI was on PS2 so a PS3 should not be hindering it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ardan

PS3 Limitations.

---

Bull. XI was on the PS2 and 360

It's got nothing to do with limitations and all to do with development time.

FFXI's animations were hand-crafted and the only special animations they had to worry about were for weapon skills and a few instant moves that had shared animations + floating effects.
FFXIV's animations are motion-capped and share animations between races. To make race-unique neutral battle stances that varied that much, they would also have to adjust the transitions into every special attack move or else chaining attacks would look weird. If they add animations, all they have to do is make sure that one battle animation set is flawless. If they add new races, all they would have to do is make sure the animation skeletons line up, rather than craft all that from scratch.

FFXIV system lets them add animations more easily and makes adding new races not a gigantic pain in the arse. They can add 10 animations for everyone in the same span of time it takes to add 1 animation for each race/gender. Don't get me wrong, unique battle stances would be cool but... I'd rather have flashy animations for all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jim_Berry

I'm surprised that different races don't have different weapon stances like they did in FFXI:

Example of MNK battle stance of different races:
http://www.ffxionline.com/forums/att...mnkstances.gif

---

We learn fighting in specific guild, if you wield a spear you only learn that in gridania, swordfigthing is only learned in the ul'da Gladiator guild,... and all of us have the same masters (as Long as we have the same class) wouldn't it be weird if every race would have a different stance while learning the same style under the same master?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tam_Hawkins

We learn fighting in specific guild, if you wield a spear you only learn that in gridania, swordfigthing is only learned in the ul'da Gladiator guild,... and all of us have the same masters (as Long as we have the same class) wouldn't it be weird if every race would have a different stance while learning the same style under the same master?

---

Beat me to it, exactly how I always passed it off.

Hahahahaha. ERm... what was I thinking... oh... how would the different races hold a bow... Really can't imagine different stances for some weapons. Other than giving us a lefty/righty option(which would be nice).

All joking aside, it would be nice to see some variety between the models.

SE has already introduced race-specific idles and sitting stances. They may not have to be race specific, but having a /changepose for weapons doesn't sound too off the wall.

I really love the idea,it adds some ''uniqueness'' to each race and please stop making excuses for the devs or blaming the ps3 as mentioned b4,FFXI was also on ps2 and Xbox. So far, the only differences i've seen are the rogo holding a spear or an axe which totally makes sense. I really want to see some diversity, please Yoshi-P and co., get out of this mentality of re-using assets (same armor set, enemy .... change color and called it new or different, argh,come on, i hate that with a passion). It feels like they're taking advantage of our love for the franchise.

1.0 had D: