server maintenence ruins the "predict the fall of garuda" event?

I think Bayohne must have /heart attack when he saw the 5hr maintenance at home, too.
lots angry ppl will pop.

Rabble Rabbe Rabble!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Filtiarne

>Implying Richard is a Japanese name
>Implying The Great Gatsby was a Japanese novel.

---

Implying that spaghetti tastes better than lasagna.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Deltara

Implying that spaghetti tastes better than lasagna.

---

>Implying you know what I am implying.

Honestly, most of the ex-FFXI gamers should know to expect maintenence. Like at least 2 of them. :p should have taken it into account in your guess!

I say they should just keep the countdown going as is, to spare themselves the headache of figuring out when each server went down and subtracting that servers time from each individual entry after figuring out which person belongs to which server.

After all, you were supposed to predict how long it would take for her to go down after the patch went live. You should have forseen the downtime.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Azurymber

of course it does. Lets say my friends and I prepared prior to the patch to try to get first kill. With a 5 hour maintenance some would have to go to work, school, etc. It essentially interrupts ppl in the process of trying to win. When the server reopens it will be 5am est and 2am pst. There will be a lot less ppl on trying and ppl who sacrificed their sleep schedule or took time out of their life to try to kill it (yes some ppl do that) will have given up on rushing for it.

---

The problem with this thinking is that we did not know *when* the patch was going to be released prior to the contest. Therefore, any plans made could only be tentative at best because you had no timetable. The fact that you could meet up at all after patch was random chance, SE could have just as easily said "sorry maintenance is extended til 1am, and servers woudl have opened at inconvenient times anyway.

Long story short, its perfectly fair. Nowhere in the contest did it say patch had to conform to tentatively scheduled plans.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Psion

Honestly, most of the ex-FFXI gamers should know to expect maintenence. Like at least 2 of them. :p should have taken it into account in your guess!

I say they should just keep the countdown going as is, to spare themselves the headache of figuring out when each server went down and subtracting that servers time from each individual entry after figuring out which person belongs to which server.

After all, you were supposed to predict how long it would take for her to go down after the patch went live. You should have forseen the downtime.

---

Maybe SE should add a disclaimer to their contests in the future
*Please note that we have incompetent employees and are unlikely to release a working patch on time. Take our fail into consideration when making your guess.

It is likely they will count the time from when the servers go back up and not the little time we had.

Also the fact they closed all, so no one can be killing it while another server wont even load XD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Azurymber

So anyone who made their prediction based on a continuous party trying to kill garuda will have been screwed.

---

We all sat through so many patches and every damn time servers chrashed, characters vanished, teleports failed, servers required emergency maintenances, etc. and people still thought there would be a win in under 5 hours?
Well that's their own fault then.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Filtiarne

>Implying you know what I am implying.

---

>Implying Delta doesn't know what you're implying.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lux_Rayna

The problem with this thinking is that we did not know *when* the patch was going to be released prior to the contest. Therefore, any plans made could only be tentative at best because you had no timetable. The fact that you could meet up at all after patch was random chance, SE could have just as easily said "sorry maintenance is extended til 1am, and servers woudl have opened at inconvenient times anyway.

Long story short, its perfectly fair. Nowhere in the contest did it say patch had to conform to tentatively scheduled plans.

---

it has nothing to do with when the patch is released, it has to do with the servers being up for 2 hours and then going down.
If they don't count the 2 hours than a party who has completed the pre-reqs prior maintenence coming back up might defeat it in an hour. The fight will be tallied as an hour but in reality it took them 3 hours.

If they do count the 2 hours then instead of 40 parties being ready to try the fight, due to the 5 hours only 10 parties might still have the 8 ppl with pre-reqs done. Thus the average time to complete garuda would increase.