3.1 Balance/QoL Request Megathread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Demi_God

Actually its 6-7% with BV up, not 14%.

---

You should test Foe again I think, I tested it recently and Foe brings 6%-7% magic damage, and 13%-14% with BV.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Clarkamite

Explain to me how that's not massive. If I'm understanding you correctly, 6-7% per magic skill used. Over the course of an entire 10 minute fight? That's small? What about in the case of even longer fights? What about fights heavy with AOE like A2S? So adding 100-200 DPS at current endgame fights is small?

---

Entire 10 minute fight??? Foe drains mana...
If You spend ALL your mana using Foe, You are gonna be able to keep it 31% of time up...If You have to bring Mana or TP regen that 31% is reduced easily to 15%...
10 minutes fight, Foe 31% time up, 3 minutes and 6 seconds bringing +6-7 % magic damage is NOT massive...
Foe is pretty good since DPS checks can be aborded with Foe and BV, but It's situational, not massive...

Summoner: Place command for pet should teleport the pet to the location ( so it don't have to walk ) kinda like how Machinist's can chang they turrets location easy cause it just despawn and spawn at new location.

If they did that, Summoners could tank with their pets by teleporting them around the battlefield and avoiding all damage. They could basically keep the enemy in a constant chase where the Egi never gets hit because they're teleported away when the mob gets close. They would have to put a CD on Place if they made it an instant teleport. I think turrets can be teleported because they aren't on the enmity table i think?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jonnycbad

If they did that, Summoners could tank with their pets by teleporting them around the battlefield and avoiding all damage. They could basically keep the enemy in a constant chase where the Egi never gets hit because they're teleported away when the mob gets close. They would have to put a CD on Place if they made it an instant teleport. I think turrets can be teleported because they aren't on the enmity table i think?

---

hardly think it would be worth it to keep teleport your titan egi around just so it can avoid damage cause outside of dungeon/raids/world boss and some fates titan egi hardly takes any damage at all anyway.
It would lose agro fast to anyway as it would not be getting any hit onto the target to keep agro, oh and any class that need to be "flank/behind target" would be so mad at you.

MCH
- Ricochet gets a similar damage formula has Flare/Holy. Secondary hit deals full damage to primary target, and diminishing returns on damage for every other target afterwards. For a 60s cooldown skill, it's kind of lack luster in everything outside of single target bosses (which even alexander lacks at times). The amount of enemies that can dilute the secondary hit in dungeons and some raid environments really downplays the skill as something you get at level 60.
-More bonus effects on MCH weaponskills/abilities through ammo consumption. They passed it off as one of MCH's main functions, but it seems incredibly under utilized when you look at abilties like hot shot, lead shot and gauss round. It does nothing for the former 2 other than to add 20 potency on the initial hit, and no skills actually require ammo to be executed.

BRD
-Rework Straighter Shot's proc detection. It occurs too late into a typical weaponskill cooldown that you'll never catch the proc unless you purposely delay your weapon skill.
-Rework River of blood to give a stacking buff that boosts the damage of your next Bloodletter or Rain of Death. It'd function better with the cast times introduced by WM.
-Redo/rework Wanderer's Minuet. It's functionally the exact same skill as machinist's GB. It ends up pigeon holing both classes to have the same foundation of gameplay and feels like a really wasted oppertunitiy. They could've done something like have WM to have cast times, reduce GCDs to 1.5 seconds with reduced TP cost, and no damage bonus while enabling the use of Empyreal and Ironjaws.

BLM
-Thunder series is not on GCD but still has cast times. This would allow them to quick cast thundercloud procs without disrupting their enochian timers to a greater degree.

Ninja - Increase Shukuchi range to 25 yards and change it to not break Hide.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Greywolfamakir

You should test Foe again I think, I tested it recently and Foe brings 6%-7% magic damage, and 13%-14% with BV.

---

Perhaps you should test Foe's again and post your results, because I'm not sure what led you to that conclusion.

No Foe's, B2 in party (no food/buffs of any kind): 372 - 411 damage range, not counting crits

Regular Foe's, B2 in party (same conditions as above): 410 - 452 damage range, not counting crits

10% increase, as the tooltip says.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Geardagas

BARD

Increase potency on some attacks.

I understand we're a support class and that our DPS should be naturally lower, but our support simply isn't strong enough to warrant a DPS gap this significant.

---

You mean under 200 dps behind the #1? Get out or get gud.

- Lower cast time of Fire IV and Blizzard IV
- Lower potency of Fire IV and Blizzard IV to sync up with Lowered Cast Times.
- Give a buff to cast while on the go. (reasonable cool down)
- No GCD on Thunder proc's.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xenon_S

- A shukuchi change would be really nice. MNK's shoulder tackle is 30s CD, DRG has Spineshatter Dive and Dragonfire Dive, both are on 60s CD. NINs only have Shukuchi which is 60s CD.

---

Spineshatter dive is 40 second cooldown.
Dragonfire dive is 120 seconds.

Other than that, your suggestions for nin were pretty tame, and that's good.