mass ban would make people think "i could be next so i better stop botting"
and stop future botters from taking the risk of downloading a bot.
if i was botting and avoided a mass ban, i would not think that. They did mass bans in XI and what did it achive? Nothing. It was either "get claim bot or gtfo our alliance". And sadly due to that and me not wanting to cheat, I was unable to do HNM's for a while until enough of my friends were confident to do it as a small group and just hope we out claim. More and more people got hacks and bots for XI, the mass banning did nothing.
Unfortunately, Shinigami, your method would cause crafting to become even more tedious with random screens popping up like that. And eventually, botters will be able to get around it. Your idea may work initially, but then, people will complain of its futility, and in the long run, will not be able to halt botters. D:
As for botany and mining....well, I can't say about mining, but in botany, EVERYONE bots. Otherwise, how will we get our lumber and logs?
Exactly. It's now a part of their business strategy, which is why SE should not wait. The harm's already being done. You'll actually do more harm to wait. As mentioned, when botters are banned shard prices will go up. The botters will have cheated their way to cheaper advancement. Same way the earliest goldsmiths levelled GS for basically free until the silver needle nerf made it painful.
These people make a living and a name off exhausting illegitimate imbalance, in hopes of finishing before it's caught. And SE lets them.
Silver needles were legal and it's still not right that the first R50 GS'ers basically got free rides and free millions at the same time while everyone behind them got a painful grind for **** profit. But that's just the breaks. This isn't even legal.
When they raise the level cap, these people will bot to try to ride that bubble. If they are not stung in an epic holocaust and sent straight to ban, to not pass suspension...then SE will have failed their jobs and the game is essentially worse than Detroit: Zero reason to stay. Every reason to leave.
This game is making a name for itself as a nest and haven of cheaters. The only reason it's not known for its infestation of RMT is because they have better games to profit from. Unfortunately RMT are smarter than playing cheaters. They follow the fame and fortune. We have so many cheaters on this server who are just waiting for that game to turn the corner so they can be kings of the hill. They're too stupid to move on, and unlike RMT figure someone, somewhere, is impressed by their achievements or eventually will be.
Ironically our biggest botters on the server are the server's biggest jokes already and have no hope of earning any respect for what they've gained. Even if they aren't banned, they're essentially finished.
Recently found someone using a fish bot at the ferry docks in Ul'dah - no bait, yet they continued to jig in the same pattern (middle, left, right) and did not respond to any tells for approx. five minutes.
It was only after I messaged another of their linkshell members that they finally disconnected and reconnected with a poorly constructed story as to why they didn't reply.
As I've come to learn, this same person is also accusing another of the same offense; talk about pot calling the kettle black! :rolleyes:
Call me crazy if you want but im a botanist lvl 40 and im no botter. As for the solution i got that already as explained in the post, but they could make that "security" likea bonus so instead of being a downer it would be someting good. like everytime that "security" would appear (once every 4-5 craft), it would give an instant 20% progress with lots of quality