Are we alone?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SturmChurro

I could, I'd be impartial when it comes to work. :)

---

Id be too relaxed to be a mod tbh, enforcing rules on others is definitely not my forte especially on people I like

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SassyAssassin

Id be too relaxed to be a mod tbh, enforcing rules on others is definitely not my forte especially on people I like

---

Honestly I would be rather lax on everyone. I know people get heated and I know people like to argue. That's all fine. If things get to a point I felt like action needed to be taken I would be like "Hey this right here? *points to post* Please don't do it like this."

That would be all the action I would take unless it just kept going. Then I would have to put in forum suspensions...and personally...I think there shouldn't be a limit on suspensions unless whatever the person was doing was extremely...harsh.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by P0W3RK1D

I think that reading the healer role forums, and comparing that to the state of healers in game is enough proof that the devs do not read the forums.

---

Not really, they do listen but just dont care for our whims for healing

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Renalt

Honestly I would be rather lax on everyone. I know people get heated and I know people like to argue. That's all fine. If things get to a point I felt like action needed to be taken I would be like "Hey this right here? *points to post* Please don't do it like this."

That would be all the action I would take unless it just kept going. Then I would have to put in forum suspensions...and personally...I think there shouldn't be a limit on suspensions unless whatever the person was doing was extremely...harsh.

---

Yes it’s what I have in mind if I imagine I had to monitor a forum.
I am grateful though, lately I have been talking about nipples and a bunch of stuff that didn’t have much to do with the game and didn’t get banned, hopefully the mods that do read get entertained themselves as well from time to time xD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SassyAssassin

Hey I finally found my people! So those birds huh? Mighty suspicious if you ask me

---

Birds are fake. They are winged surveillance robots created and run by the government! All of them. I don't have a source on this, but you can trust me, I promise. You heard it on the internet, so it's obviously true.

I was slightly disappointed because I expected a deeply philosophical question about our place in the universe. :(

How do you know that the other people on these forums aren't chatbots?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vahlnir

Birds are fake. They are winged surveillance robots created and run by the government! All of them. I don't have a source on this, but you can trust me, I promise. You heard it on the internet, so it's obviously true.

---

Erm, it's called the Open Air Act™. :^)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vahlnir

Birds are fake. They are winged surveillance robots created and run by the government! All of them. I don't have a source on this, but you can trust me, I promise. You heard it on the internet, so it's obviously true.

---

I trust you! It’s madness more people don’t #believe Im telling you!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NekoMataMata

How do you know that the other people on these forums aren't chatbots?

---

Isn't there a debate about that one person that posts here might be a chatbot AI?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Renalt

Honestly I would be rather lax on everyone. I know people get heated and I know people like to argue. That's all fine. If things get to a point I felt like action needed to be taken I would be like "Hey this right here? *points to post* Please don't do it like this."

That would be all the action I would take unless it just kept going. Then I would have to put in forum suspensions...and personally...I think there shouldn't be a limit on suspensions unless whatever the person was doing was extremely...harsh.

---

If I modded here, not a whole lot would change. I would just be looking for clear violations of forum policies, and I haven't seen much of that. Perhaps a bit of profane language I might have to toss a warning or two on. I have stated many times that I would much rather people get their frustrations out here on an internet forum than for their pipes to burst in a much worse way at their place of work, at home, a public scene, etc.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vahlnir

Birds are fake. They are winged surveillance robots created and run by the government! All of them. I don't have a source on this, but you can trust me, I promise. You heard it on the internet, so it's obviously true.

---

I believe you. But only for birds that spend a lot of time around human company. Crows, pigeons, blue jays, seagulls, etc. Majestic birds like condors, eagles, swans, various jungle birds and so forth aren't too fond of people and I think are ok. I am thoroughly convinced that the shoebill was placed her by aliens though.

So on the subject of mods translating what we say to Japanese for the devs; if that happens, I would have MAJOR concerns.

Look at the 'localization' of this game. I can only imagine what kind of scrambled garbage the Japanese devs would get from them. Or what kind of agenda they may push.

Yoshi-"Tell me, what are the Americans saying about our game?"
Loocalizer-"They love it! The healers would like their rotations made easier and pvp needs more 1 hit kill attacks. Also they said I should get a raise."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Necrotica

There are many people who assume the devs never read the NA forums. That the mods never post. There is very rare moderation/bans but nothing to point to real human beings.

With advancement in AI chatbot capabilities we could actually have absolutely 0 interactions or responses from anyone that works for Sqaure Enix.

IF that were to be the case, how would it change your posting habits here? I complain a lot, don't expect anyone important to read it, but I can always hope and use it to vent. But if this was truly just some random website the devs abandoned years ago to maintained by bots...don't know.

We can talk to eachother, have debates, share ideas, but knowing for an absolute fact that this is a dead site as far as the devs are concerned would be sad.

And I am starting to think that is the case more each day.

---

I mean, is it really that strange that the devs don't read the through this cesspool here where 99% of the "players" are either trolls or people who believe "Your game sucks lol i hate what you did" is constructive helpful criticism.

If i were the devs i also wouldn't dig through this pile of rubbish here to find that one comment beneath the myriads of trollposts who could actually provide helpful insight into the state of the game. They still do however, if some threads gain really high post numbers as seen by the male bunny thread. But digging through every thread and post? I think they have better to do than that and rightfully so.

The possibility of an AI chatbot maintaining a forum rather than real human interaction raises some important questions about the purpose and potential impact of these types of forums. If a forum is purely maintained by AI, it might not provide meaningful engagement or a way to voice feedback to the developers. In turn, this could negatively affect the user experience and the sense of community on the forums.

One potential solution to this issue would be for Square Enix to actively engage with the North American forums and provide real human interaction. This could involve regular moderation and management by employees, responding to user feedback and questions, and fostering a sense of community among users. By doing so, Square Enix could improve the user experience and help to build a stronger sense of community on the forums.

Another solution could be for Square Enix to create alternative channels for user engagement and feedback, such as surveys, polls, or direct communication through social media or email. This could help to ensure that users are still able to voice their opinions and provide feedback to the developers, even if the forums are not being actively moderated.

Ultimately, it is important for developers to understand the importance of fostering a sense of community among their users and to provide meaningful engagement and feedback mechanisms. Whether through human interaction or alternative channels, Square Enix has the opportunity to improve the user experience on the North American forums and build a stronger sense of community among its users.

- ChatGPT

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Amenara

Isn't there a debate about that one person that posts here might be a chatbot AI?

---

Maybe. What they don't know is that I'm an AI.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NekoMataMata

Maybe. What they don't know is that I'm an AI.

---

The problem with Artificial Intelligence is that it's regularly defeated by Natural Stupidity...

I have been banned once, so i Guess there Is at least someone

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Deveryn

They constantly tell us in streams that they check the forums for feedback. It's your problem if you choose not to believe.

---

You keep on believing that. There isa reason why it's widely known that most changes happen only because of outrage on the Japanese forums. Also, please link me stream where they explicitly tell they monitor these forums for feedback. "Constantly".

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RitsukoSonoda

The problem with Artificial Intelligence is that it's regularly defeated by Natural Stupidity...

---

I was programed with natural stupidity. What now?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NekoMataMata

How do you know that the other people on these forums aren't chatbots?

---

I assure you I am human. I participate in many human activities, such as inhaling oxygen, consuming food for fuel, and wearing skin.

are you afraid

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by boopadoop

are you afraid

---

I am boop, save me

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Meowdyj

You keep on believing that. There isa reason why it's widely known that most changes happen only because of outrage on the Japanese forums. Also, please link me stream where they explicitly tell they monitor these forums for feedback. "Constantly".

---

pick a stream. Every Duty Commenced, they mention it at the end.

It's not their fault if the other sections offer little in the way of actual feedback. Y'all spend way too much time about whining about feedback that doesn't get through or giving feedback they've already responded to. I've seen one good thread in the past few months about endgame gear.

This is the front page of general

Quote:

---

gear unlocks
patch cycle length
are the mods here
???
3rd party
trans
community
patch cycle
patch cycle
au ra
patch cycle
possible actual suggestion
necro
elezen
3rd party
omega
female hroth (already in progress)
sightseeing
hair
squads

---

There are two, maybe three threads there worth a look. You can't tell me the devs actually need to look at and respond to all that BS or even have community reps pass that along to begin with.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Skiros

The possibility of an AI chatbot maintaining a forum rather than real human interaction raises some important questions about the purpose and potential impact of these types of forums. If a forum is purely maintained by AI, it might not provide meaningful engagement or a way to voice feedback to the developers. In turn, this could negatively affect the user experience and the sense of community on the forums.

One potential solution to this issue would be for Square Enix to actively engage with the North American forums and provide real human interaction. This could involve regular moderation and management by employees, responding to user feedback and questions, and fostering a sense of community among users. By doing so, Square Enix could improve the user experience and help to build a stronger sense of community on the forums.

Another solution could be for Square Enix to create alternative channels for user engagement and feedback, such as surveys, polls, or direct communication through social media or email. This could help to ensure that users are still able to voice their opinions and provide feedback to the developers, even if the forums are not being actively moderated.

Ultimately, it is important for developers to understand the importance of fostering a sense of community among their users and to provide meaningful engagement and feedback mechanisms. Whether through human interaction or alternative channels, Square Enix has the opportunity to improve the user experience on the North American forums and build a stronger sense of community among its users.

- ChatGPT

---

Has all this actually been using ChatGPT? LOL

More than just this thread? ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Deveryn

pick a stream. Every Duty Commenced, they mention it at the end.

It's not their fault if the other sections offer little in the way of actual feedback. Y'all spend way too much time about whining about feedback that doesn't get through or giving feedback they've already responded to. I've seen one good thread in the past few months about endgame gear.

This is the front page of general



There are two, maybe three threads there worth a look. You can't tell me the devs actually need to look at and respond to all that BS or even have community reps pass that along to begin with.

---

Who gives a shit what the frontpage looks like? The duty of a community manager is to look and filter threads that are worth forwarding feedback for. In any social medium, Twitter, Reddit, Forums, there are always threads or comments that don't matter yet it's their job to look at. It's the definition of the responsibilities of a community manager.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Meowdyj

Who gives a shit what the frontpage looks like? The duty of a community manager is to look and filter threads that are worth forwarding feedback for. In any social medium, Twitter, Reddit, Forums, there are always threads or comments that don't matter yet it's their job to look at. It's the definition of the responsibilities of a community manager.

---

Right. I'm telling you they do that and there's almost nothing to pass along. :rolleyes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Deveryn

pick a stream. Every Duty Commenced, they mention it at the end.

It's not their fault if the other sections offer little in the way of actual feedback. Y'all spend way too much time about whining about feedback that doesn't get through or giving feedback they've already responded to. I've seen one good thread in the past few months about endgame gear.

This is the front page of general



There are two, maybe three threads there worth a look. You can't tell me the devs actually need to look at and respond to all that BS or even have community reps pass that along to begin with.

---

Typically, as with other game forums, the community managers would give official posts on the higher quality threads, showing that they've been noticed and recorded as feedback. That would at least encourage people to make higher quality threads.
As it is now, people feel like they have to yell louder and louder to get the attention of devs who don't acknowledge they're even listening and it eventually gets hyperbolic to the point of shitposting.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VerdeLuck

Typically, as with other game forums, the community managers would give official posts on the higher quality threads, showing that they've been noticed and recorded as feedback. That would at least encourage people to make higher quality threads.
As it is now, people feel like they have to yell louder and louder to get the attention of devs who don't acknowledge they're even listening and it eventually gets hyperbolic to the point of shitposting.

---

People here mostly want to yell at each other and about SE and can't handle contrary opinions. Any good ideas get drowned out by inane nonsense like these threads.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SassyAssassin

I am boop, save me

---

https://youtu.be/4e9c-B_lH08