Field Commander set: can the requirements to earn it be reviewed?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Esmoire

I quite like where it is. 300 matches theoretically, though the better you get, the fewer it will take.

---

Uh, we are talking about Frontline here where wins and losses are determined solely by luck?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JamieRose

Uh, we are talking about Frontline here where wins and losses are determined solely by luck?

---

A single match is luck. Many matches is your ability. If you still have <30% winrate after hundreds of matches, you should be re-evaluating your approach.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Commander_Justitia

You know this winrate in the pic used to be a lot better. 2 revamps and its even sub 50%. If I would play another 1000 matches I would probably be sub 40% like you.

It is a bit too much clusterfck nowadays. It used to be more useful to win just by leading people.

The Field Commander set should be dyeable btw, it is not even really pure white..

https://i.ibb.co/7QBs768/image.png

---

To go back to this, I agree. Feel like 6.1 PvP mitigates skill index more than previous. It's so much more volatile and carry power is diminished without a three or four stack.

It's suppose to be an evergreen achievement just like the mounts. Just something you get eventually. It's still less of a troll than the titles.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Commander_Justitia

The Field Commander set should be dyeable btw, it is not even really pure white..

---

Yeah... yeah it should.

This problem could very easily be fixed by having Frontline set to a random map draw upon que pop instead of 1 map per week. You would have the chance to make progress on your coat every single day.

(Okay I know its 1 map per 4 days, point still stands lol.)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikoto

I mean, no? You can just keep doing the roulette over and over on that day, but it's definitely slower seeing as there's 3 other maps to cycle through.

---

These rewards aren't something that is meant to be acquired quickly. If you are too impatient... well that's a "you" problem then.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nikoto

I mean, no? You can just keep doing the roulette over and over on that day, but it's definitely slower seeing as there's 3 other maps to cycle through.

---

It's actually faster, because in the past only Shatter would pop for FL.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Esmoire

This is actually a lapse in basic numeration as well as competition psychology.

First of all, everyone has "randomness", including your opponent.

The macro is your ability to mitigate randomness. This is why people in very random games like poker or TCGs can have positive winrates.

---

I'm fully aware that the other teams are fighting luck just as much as I am. That doesn't make it any less frustrating to lose over and over based on that luck after twenty minutes of high-intensity struggle.

Also, people playing poker or TCGs are playing solo. Their performance is entirely down to how they personally handle their situation.

In Frontline, whatever skill you may have comes down to 1/24th of the team's performance. And even if you're the best player ever, the other team might have more people who are just as good.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sinstrel

This problem could very easily be fixed by having Frontline set to a random map draw upon que pop instead of 1 map per week. You would have the chance to make progress on your coat every single day.

(Okay I know its 1 map per 4 days, point still stands lol.)

---

That wouldn't remotely fix it. It would make the situation four times worse, because I would have to queue for Frontline and hope for Seal Rock instead of queuing on Seal Rock day.

I have a 40ish% winrate overall, few more wins for the coat but I still have days where I just can’t win. Even if I’m playing the same. Feels pretty rng based to me. *shrug* you can also be a player who literally does nothing in every match and still get the coat.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Commander_Justitia

You know this winrate in the pic used to be a lot better. 2 revamps and its even sub 50%. If I would play another 1000 matches I would probably be sub 40% like you.

It is a bit too much clusterfck nowadays. It used to be more useful to win just by leading people.

The Field Commander set should be dyeable btw, it is not even really pure white..

https://i.ibb.co/7QBs768/image.png

---

Really want that to be dyed, it is such a good coat.
And I agree it is chaotic.

But overall the map rotation is also what holds back the grinding, not exactly just the wins. There are days you cannot play so you might miss the map you want to grind or days you are only losing, making it feel like you wasted your time.

Best advice i could give is to just play without worrying too much on the achievement and have a set amount of matches you want to do per day. (I also need this mentality if I want to get the Shatter title from 300 wins so Rhalgr grant me strenght, still at 121).