Increased Droprate for Onion Knight/Puff of Darkness?

It kinda sucks too cause it's harder than ever to get WoD wins, at least until the expansion with more gear, because all the people who could do coil are just doing coil instead or have quit until 3.0 since there is no point in getting gear atm. I've been in several WoD this week where the group couldn't clear the first boss and just abandoned.

I wish I could give a million likes to this. It took me running ST nonstop for three weeks to finally get a Onion Knight. RNGesus HATES me on everything. I have run WoD well over 100 times trying to get Puff of Darkness with no luck at all, and it's so depressing! Please increase drop rate!

They should just make the Puff and the O.Knight part of the optional quest items along with the Carboncoat, Carbontwine. Gift of the Archmagus quest iirc.

Or make the chest appear 75%-100% of the time. I have terrible luck with lotting on minions (always roll under 50) and whenever I roll a good number 90+ someone out lots me by 1 or 2 points...Oh I should mention I have don't ST 177 times, and I have actually seen the chest appear like 20-30 times in all those runs.

It would be easier to get if there was a chest for each alliance, rather than one for the entire raid.

Rolling against (up to) 7 is a lot better than rolling against (up to) 23.

I finally got my Onion Knight Card. Even before I had one, I kind of liked the rarity of the card. The minion, eh...not so much.

I think the biggest problem with them is how people who already have them, can still roll on them.

Why is that even a thing? As if rolling against an entire alliance isn't bad enough, you have people who already have the thing still rolling on it, and adding more competition for those who actually don't have it, or even outright taking it from them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OMEGA_HACK

They should just make the Puff and the O.Knight part of the optional quest items along with the Carboncoat, Carbontwine. Gift of the Archmagus quest iirc.

Or make the chest appear 75%-100% of the time. I have terrible luck with lotting on minions (always roll under 50) and whenever I roll a good number 90+ someone out lots me by 1 or 2 points...Oh I should mention I have don't ST 177 times, and I have actually seen the chest appear like 20-30 times in all those runs.

---

That would completely lose the point of they being rare vanity items and would make someone "waste" a week of actual useful items just to get a minion LOL But since there's like 23 other people to roll against you IF it drops, I think increase of drop rate is reasonable.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CGMidlander

It would be easier to get if there was a chest for each alliance, rather than one for the entire raid.

Rolling against (up to) 7 is a lot better than rolling against (up to) 23.

---

hm, i don't think so. probably it is better, but far away from a lot better. you will still need to roll a 85+ to even have a chance to get it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tint

you will still need to roll a 85+ to even have a chance to get it

---

I have lost out to the Puff of Darkness twice with rolls over 90. Rolling against 20+ people makes baby RNGesus even more cruel...haha

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ditto

I think the biggest problem with them is how people who already have them, can still roll on them.

Why is that even a thing? As if rolling against an entire alliance isn't bad enough, you have people who already have the thing still rolling on it, and adding more competition for those who actually don't have it, or even outright taking it from them.

---

Yes! They are non tradeable and non sellable, so literally the only thing you can do if you get a second one is throw it away.

Someone in my fc accidentally rolled on a second one and won it... she felt terrible, but you can't even give it away.

If you have already "used" the minion, you should not be able to roll.