Dark Knight

The comment about it being a magic/parry/dodge tank worries me. Because that's what they tried to do with Rune Fencer in XI and they failed horribly because it struggles to survive physical based damage and the % reduction of Paladin's cooldowns/shields just totally outclass its resistance to magic damage. It could turn into 2.0 Warrior all over again if they don't balance it properly (Being different does not make you better, or even preferable as a niche case). Nobody is going to care if you're only taking like 1/3 of the magical damage from Megaflare or whatever if Ravensbeak is doing 2/3 more (Than a standard tank). Most of the attacks in this game that are actually expected to kill tanks are large or continuous physical hits (Death Sentence, Ravensbeak, Bahamut's Claws, Mountain Buster, Hood Swing, Double Wicked Wheel). Being resistant to magic damage more than physical damage doesn't help you survive any of that. The only thing it does help you with are reduce the damage to things like Earthen Heart, Mega Flare, Avatar Lasers/Mines in T8...none of which is really expected to kill the tank with the exception of some unfortunate mine juggling in T8.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EdwinLi

I will like to point out the reason why Dark Knight may not have a class is because it is a Advance Job.

Yoshi-P mentioned back in 2.0 he has plans for Advance Jobs that will require may be 2 Jobs to unlock such as the example he used being Red Mage requiring both Black Mage and White Mage.

---

Someone who actually uses their brain when reading that statement! And not jumping on the 'get rid of the classes/yay no classes anymore' train!

Sure, adjustments here and there will be nice, but getting rid of the current classes? You'll be butchering the lore and backstories of three city-states to the point that history may as well take a dump people obviously don't care for it. Asides from PLD, none of the jobs have ANY special history with the three starter city-states. Let's use Gridania as an example~

Gridania's lore involving the elementals will be utterly destroyed if Conjurer got removed. You can hardly say its easy to replace conjurers with White Mages considering their powers have a substantial difference, with White Mage already established a source of their power (Amdapor City) and how Conjurers have a deep history with interactions of the forest's elementals.. If DRGs were to replace Lancers? May as well cut out the entire history of Wood Wailers then, because Dragoons came from Ishgard, so congratulations, you just eliminated a third of Gridania's battle force!

I don't mind adjustments. I want jobs themselves to have more prominent features and skills, but cutting out the class system is not an option.

It's not hard to imagine why DRK may not require a class. Of Limsa Lominsa, Gridania, Ul'dah and Ishgard, Ishgard is the one city-state which ties a job so heavily into its history that it doesn't have a base class in its city of origin; Dragoon. Or if it does, it's expected by lore for Dragoons to lead the war against the Dravanian Horde, so it remains a big part of Ishgard. Seeing this, it won't be hard to imagine the expansion having other cities with heavy roots with jobs instead of classes.

great DK was a tank we need more cool tanks, and this is not ffXI so please people, stop to want this game to be another game

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Viridiana

Well, and those of us who really wanted a sword-based DD >_>

---

Maybe SAM will be he answer to your pleas?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rosalynd

And there goes one iconic class butchered by the XIV team....

Truly disappointed in it being a tank.

---

You realize drk was a tank before a dps right?Check out ff4

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OmniKLD

You realize drk was a tank before a dps right?Check out ff4

---

Pseudo tank. Kain was actually the better tank in that game before Cecil became a paladin.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Erudain

Maybe SAM will be he answer to your pleas?

---

Maybe. Of the two, I'd rather have had DRK be the DD, I think; but time will tell. Honestly, neither of them make me think of tanks, but a lot of the posters here were sure that one or both (or neither) would become a tank. I'm not averse to the idea, so I'm taking it in stride.

Of course, there's still an opportunity for SE to make SAM a magic DPS job. :)

No base class? Could we finally get rid of the others then?

Shame about awkwardly shoving everything into the 3 role system. But great swords are a tempting offer.

no Scythe weapon? maybe will a add the scythe.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gramul

No base class? Could we finally get rid of the others then?

---

Makes what they did with Summoner and Scholar just appear awkward and forced at this point since it looks like they're going to just do away with the diverging class thing altogether at this point.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RagnaBahamut

no Scythe weapon? maybe will a add the scythe.

---

I love XI, but Dark Knights have always traditionally been sword users. Either one-handers in IV or great swords in X-2 or XI. Yoshi-P even said a long time ago that he didn't understand why they would use Scythes.