God forbid you actually bought the Collector's Edition for the Security Token or Art book or any of other selection of physical goods.
Printable View
Well to be fair, it came with a mini soundtrack, dvd with cutscenes, art book, and security token in addition to in-game items. The in-game items were just an extra bonus to those tangible items.
And yes, this excludes the digital deluxe edition. I can't say I disagree in that case.
Still, I'm not sure how this pertains to selling previously available items for cash.
I agree with your post for all the points made. I do want to point out, though, that I have experienced an MMORPG in the past raise it's subscription fee while I was playing. I want to say it was EverQuest II, but I'm not positive on that and I really don't care enough to go back and try to find it. So it does happen. And personally I'd rather a subscription increase of $1-$2 a month over putting in a cash shop. It feels more honest to me since I knew it was a possibility in the long run.
It's always felt shady to me when a company changes the way a customer funds it like this (more the how, not the how much like a subscription increase). I went into the game with the concept of "It's a monthly subscription game. All evidence shows I get all access to the game for that subscription. Of course, I'll have to buy expansions and the like." And Yoshi P has made numerous points about how the game needs to be a monthly subscription model and the benefits of it. No where that I have seen anywhere has there even been a hint to a cash shop for anything more than appearance change, server change, and (maybe one day...) name change services like most MMOs, no matter their subscription model, have. Generally the additional cost is because it's a one-off service feature.
I'm against cash shop. I have the collector's edition. I played the beta of 1.0 right before release and decided I didn't care for it. I was working in retail when 1.0 came out. I wandered by the gaming section a while after release and saw a CE box for about $30 I think it was since no one wanted it. I scooped it up. I love the nifty things you get in the CE boxes. The physical things are what usually attract me to those. Having the CE and being against a cash shop is not hypocritical in the least, even though you try to imply it is.
Honestly, there was a wonderful woman who got turned into a meme that once said "I ain't got time for that!"
I have a limited amount of time to play. would I rather spend my time getting this fancy hat and gear, or would I rather make some gil, and practice for ScoB? Ill pay $10 dollars for my looks, thank you.
in other news, 1125 posts? really people? #nolife