I appreciate the thoughtfulness, eloquence and effort you put into this post, but you tend to make a recurring mistake in the context and content of your replies.

Your posts often lack empathy. This means that you often fail to put yourself in the shoes of the poster to see were the request is coming from. It's much too easy to post about all the reasons why you think someone's opinion is wrong, in the context of a discussion. The purpose of this forum, from SE's perspective is for us (players) to find common ground that can help them make decisions about the best course of action to take in developing the world of Vanadiel.

Just like your replies and evidenced by your post here, your replies are not gospel. You are not in charge of the forums. Finally, I disagree with Likes being sufficient for positive discussion. Even if you disagree with someone's post, try to find a narrative that establishes common ground.

TLDR: You have a tendency to be very divisive and just shutdown whoever you're talking to. It's easy to dismiss people in a reply, and a simple Like is not sufficient for discourse. Instead, find common ground about what you'd like to see in the context of another person's request. Show SE that we can agree on things.