I've been reading posts on this forum all day about PLD and possible adjustments and fixes... but it seems like most of these ideas don't really fix the underlying problem...
You can mess with enmity formulas all day, and give PLD 100% Cover Job Trait, Give them 5 provokes natively, what have you.
That won't fix it. It still won't make people think "hmmm I need a PLD in this party to tank in Abyssea." for most things.
People would still just have the MNK go all out and Tank all day while doing ridiculous damage, and just have the WHM cure bomb them.
Why?
Because the Mob dies faster doing that. Sometimes having the best offense IS the best defense.
Why should all the DDs hold back so the PLD can keep hate, if there is no consequence to them taking hate? (and in MNKs case, extreme benefit.)
Its a balancing headache really.
The only "solutions" I can think of are:
1) Make the new Mobs so ridiculously powerful that nothing can tank it except a PLD.
(oops, but then, the game becomes rigid again. You NEED X job for X, all other jobs inferior, etc)
2) Start swinging Nerf bats.
(thats just lose/lose for everyone)
3) Buff PLDs Damage Dealing Capabilities While It Is Tanking.
Now before you all start screaming and crying that that isn't balanced, that PLD is only supposed to be 100% defense or some such, think about this idea.
For a PLD to be relevant again, it needs to evolve and adapt to how things are working now.
We need to look at why MNK excels so much now at tanking now, and apply it to PLD with some unique finesse (just slaping on "PLDcounterstanceAbility!" is kinda uninspired)
It is the duty of Paladins to defend others and doing so, makes you want to fight harder; what if a PLD got certain Damage Dealing bonuses/Abilities for Defending other players?
This concept could be centered around Cover.
Make Cover on a lower recast and make it a "stance" of sorts.
Each attack the PLD intercepts while under cover increases the PLDs "Righteousness", a special buff that increases numerically (similar to finishing moves).
Each point in Righteousness increases the PLDs Attack and Haste/FastCast. (+enimity?)
Righteousness doesn't last a long time, it decreases over time when you aren't defending someone with Cover.
Additionally, Righteousness points could be used to activate other abilities.
Such as refreshing Shield Bash, or Cover again.
Or they can be used to buff a Cure spell, Holy/Banish for increased Damage/enimity?
|
|
© SQUARE ENIX FINAL FANTASY, SQUARE ENIX, and the SQUARE ENIX logo are registered trademarks of Square Enix Holdings Co., Ltd. Vana'diel , Tetra Master, PLAYONLINE, the PLAYONLINE logo, Rise of the Zilart, Chains of Promathia, Treasures of Aht Urhgan, and Wings of the Goddess are registered trademarks of Square Enix Co., Ltd. The rating icon is a registered trademark of the Entertainment Software Association. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Online play requires internet connection. |