Results 1 to 10 of 68

Thread: Dear SE...

Dev. Posts

Hybrid View

  1. 10-24-2013 06:12 PM

  2. #2
    Player
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Ru'Lude Gardens!
    Posts
    4,310
    Quote Originally Posted by Stompa View Post
    Actually that was the exact point I was responding to. This game can still return to high numbers of players. But it needs to return to the slow progression / stratified heirarchy / effort-based rewards game. That game was hugely popular, and not dying at all. Even when people were just logging in to farm magians and woepaths these last 2 years. And much more so in the pre-Aby era. A return to that game would bring in and keep new players in the game, just like it did 11 years ago. The reason new players are quitting after a month, is that they got a free zero-effort ride from lvl 1-99 and they got the most powerful gear/weaps in FFXI in like an hour. Thats why the new players quit. Solve that problem, and return the game to gradual effort-based xp/gear-building and this game will stop losing new players.
    Something that could never be done in this FFXI even if you tried. How exactly would you make XP meaningful again? Raise the cap? Well, sounds like from what SE says it that it cant be done, that's why we now level via gear. Reset everyone's characters? Oh, that is just what would make me want to play more, my character being reset on my levels to go back and do it all over again. Simply put, XP is a dead system in this game, you cant bring it back in a meaningful way that is actual leveling at this point really.

    Depending on which period of time you are talking about new people quitting, you could be wrong. During the Abyssea age new players came and went because the game was fast to throw you into endgame but unlike many newer games, it explains nothing, you have to have either a wiki or another player holding your hand nearly the entire time to actually play the game. Not many people seem to want a game that involves spending more time reading what to do and walking around to do it than actually having fun and doing something. Not only that, but this game explains nothing about character stats either, something else which is looked down upon, since most games now days seem to make it fairly clear what stats actually do something, where as this game its all on wiki and if you don't read it, chances are, you wont know it.

    Now, if you meant during the SoA period we are currently in, then yes, people quit after getting the best things quickly, but that's for a simple reason. On top of the above things, there is nothing to do in this game right now after you get those things. Those of us who have been here a while can hold on to some hope the game we have played so long will actually become fun and playable again, but new people have no reason to really stay, and just walk away after a disappointing couple of weeks or months. At least, that's my experience with people I know or have known who quit.

    It is losing players for the reasons stated above. That doesnt mean its dying, that means it is hitting rock-bottom and needs to return to the previously successful business-model. "Some people understand" is some rare old BS. You don't have a crystal ball. We are all totally in the dark as to the future of FFXI. It might have a revival. You don't know.
    No one needs a crystal ball to understand that the game population is dying and as it dies, more people leave, as you say, the community is part of why people play this, its an online game after all, so as more people leave, the game feels emptier, people take notice, more people leave, and it continues. That, and they would either need to wipe away years of work to go back to what you describe, or they would need to make so much new content, levels, and so on, that it would take years to get enough content in the game to get to that point.

    And again, I don't miss the point here, I don't want to play an offline version. Read my post. I like the worldwide gamer community and friends in faraway lands. That is what made FFXI fun. Sitting alone in a room playing it alone on offline mode would just be heartbreaking.
    You may not want to play an offline version, but these threads have popped up a few times, obviously seems to point to only one thing... others do.
    (4)

  3. 10-25-2013 12:31 AM

  4. #4
    Player
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Ru'Lude Gardens!
    Posts
    4,310
    Quote Originally Posted by Stompa View Post
    Fixing it ;
    1)Aby lvl cap above 75. Restoration of the 'big level-gap results in no xp system' in Aby. No more 99s killing mobs and lvl 30s standing there going ding every 30 seconds. We should stop that, and go back to the original xp system, augmented with level synch, and book-pages.
    Oh I see, so you plan to strand all new players at low levels, the ass end of the game where no one is anymore. If you think people would still level jobs your sadly mistaken, and even if people did, where would they go? Gusgen, Crawlers, and so on, people wouldn't go back to Dunes, Kazham, Altepa, or anything of the sort. All this change would do at this point is stop most people from leveling new jobs while stranding new players at the low end of the game with hardly anyone else. At least with Abyssea they play with others after some time, its not nothing but soloing, which is what this would basically have people doing.

    Magian trials. The fairest, most versatile and most rewarding weapon building system in the game imo. Add new weapon groups, cool looking weaps, add new trials to existing 99 Magians, to make them competitive in SoA and later battlefields.
    Except SE seems to want to move past this system. If they would use it still, to a point, I would agree with you. I like ToM somewhat, though I have massive issues with the annoying lack of challenge, as though killing 2000 mobs which were far weaker than me during certain weathers proved I was worthy of the weapon or not. In either case, this wouldn't be to bad except it might devalue SoA weapons more which SE also seems to be trying to avoid.

    Basically bring back stratification. Ie. pay your dues if u wanna wear these shoes. As the zen masters say. New chars being pimpest in the server after a few months, is a tragic fail on every level. And this rocketing to the top of the game in a month, removes the long journeying aspect, and also removes the whole 'veterans helping new adventurers' ethos which has been the backbone of FFXI for 10 years and led to many lasting friendships.
    Being on top in a month, I agree, bad, long journey/helping new players, I disagree with. New people need help now more than ever before. Before people starting out had a lot of others around, people would noticed them and would help, but now days its all upper ended so no one sees them or helps them as much, and as you get further in this game it only gets worse as many more things pop up without telling you. For instance, a new player would know nothing of AF these days, or Limit Breaks, not unless they are told, before you might hear about it in a party, but now days, no parties. So to me, new players need help more in that aspect than ever, and really, since most people want Delve boss weapons and such to even participate in Delve, the main piece of SoA content, new people need help getting these for sure.

    I agree about having to work for something, but this game needs to stop with the stupid/annoying ways to do it. Original Delve was hard, that was how it should have been, a really hard event, best gear, hard event, simple. The fact this game hides everything behind annoyingly tedious tasks like ToM where your doing something over and over without challenge, or the fact its hidden behind super high amounts of luck like NNI or VW, those are stupid. The game needs to be about earning things but not from repeating the same event over and over again because of luck or something that says you have to, something should be simply challenging, and if you can win that challenge, you are rewarded.
    (1)

  5. 10-25-2013 10:29 AM

  6. #6
    Player
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Ru'Lude Gardens!
    Posts
    4,310
    Quote Originally Posted by Stompa View Post
    Well idk coz I was "stranded" there myself in 2004, and I had a lot of fun xping to 75 in lots of different areas. And the 'where nobody is anymore' is the whole problem, to fix it you need a system that engages players to use those old areas, a system like we had in 03-09. The only reason those areas are empty is because theres a 'leech to 99' option available. If that option is removed, the old areas will once again be filled up with new players.
    In 2004 there were people, all up till Abyssea there were people out there, but that's not now, is it? No matter what the reason, the areas are empty, and as I explained, even if you try to make people go back to old areas, it wont work, take away Abyssea, people will just do book parties, take away books, people will find something else. I am not sure where these hoards of new players are that will fill up the old areas for leveling...

    In most of the recent threads there is 'why is ffxi dying' stuff, and my point is its dying because it got made into a game you can beat while afk watching TV. That is an undemanding game. And when people don't feel the game demands anything of them, they usually /quit in boredom. My suggestions are what I think could bring back the popular core game FFXI, the alternative seems to be just this fail situation we have today.
    The thing is that with all your posts you seem to be focused on the idea that leveling is the core of the game, and wont accept the fact you cant really go back to that unless you do something to reset people. I agree that going as it is right now will not work, but you cant just say that taking leeching away from the game would fix it all, or really fix it at all.

    Take away leeching/quick leveling, and who gets hurt most? Nearly everyone in the game today has a few jobs at 99, we wont level new jobs as easily if at all, but that doesn't mean we don't have out jobs we already leveled/leeched. New players on the other hand, would be forced to level slower, taking weeks or months to reach 99, which is where everyone else is right now. That's why I say they are stranded, forced to level slowly to get to the part of the game where everyone else is, something that is not even close to the same as back in 2004 or any other pre-Abyssea period really.

    Some people including you it seems, believe that the old slow party xp to lvl75 was an evil and horrible waterboarding type of experience. But I can confirm I had more fun xping in 04-09 in challenging parties with interesting players, than I've had since Aby and Soa arrived. And the point is, if you want the game to survive, you need the new players to keep logging in and paying subs, and the reason players always did that was that they had a slower progression through the game. "This week I'm gonna go level 65-70 if it kills me!" etc. Now its just, "oh I'm lvl 30, I got stacks of forbidden keys, I will be 99 before the end of the day" /yawn & /quitgame.
    I enjoyed old XP parties for a time, when they were all I knew, and they were necessary. I no longer enjoy them or the idea of them, I did them for some time, but I realized the social aspect of it was the only part I enjoyed, the fights were boring, the challenge non-existent, and overall, it just wasn't fun for what I was doing, but it was fun for the people I did it with. Once I joined a linkshell with those people, I had no more fun in XP parties than I did just standing in my Mog House really, XP just kept me more active.

    Besides that, look, you keep talking about leveling as if its the only thing, level, level, level... As though that's all there is to the game. Yes, new players can get to level 99 before the end of a day, whup te do, that means nothing when you have no gear, no skill, no merits, no knowledge, sure, some people will see level 99 and think they are done, people with the mindset you seem to have. Others, will understand that its simply a number, a level, something that does not mean you have won. You want to speak of a journey, well, the new journey begins at 99, if a new player quits at 99 just because of the number, they are not fit for the journey.

    This game needs more content, something to keep people here, but leveling is not the place to find it, not any more.

    I disagree on Magians. I enjoyed doing f.ex 3000~ ws to build a TPbonus weapon, etc. It felt like I was being challenged, to use TP efficiently, get the required WS killshots etc. Also I like my char & enjoy watching her use WS. Also pet trials, using strats to get multiple mobs to 10% so your pet can kill them fast. Weather trials, holding like 20 mobs at 10% while waiting for the weather to change lol. And coz I earned those items by my own efforts that makes me feel like proud of it and stuff. I didn't just leech a seeker's KI and use it to buy a god-shovel.
    Seeing as I am sure they did not intend us to hold 20 mobs for weather so we can AoE WS them all to death, its not really challenging content, its just you creating your own form of challenge. I think of it like someone going in to Abyssea without Atma/Cruor buffs, its an option you choose, but its not really how SE intended it to be done. When it comes down to it, your killing hundreds or thousands of mobs which are all many levels under you, often EP or EEP now, and in the end would be rewarded one of the best weapons in the game, to me, its just not to great a system in that way, but at the same time, I wouldn't mind seeing it expanded on as it did work well.

    The other great thing about Magians is if you have a job and family etc., you can log in a few hours per evening and just chip away at your trials, and obtain your weapon gradually on your own casual timeframe. For ppl with real lives, a lot of SoA timesinks are just not possible.
    That is the best thing about ToM, and the worst thing about ToM. The weather/day trials are a complete time sink that are often impossible for people with those kind of restrictions. The fact you have to kill certain enemies in certain weathers means you can be restricted to certain zones with rare weather such as fire or water makes it impossible for some people because of the waiting. Even day trials can be a complete pain since you have to wait for your free time and the proper days to align so that you can make progress.

    As I said, ToM is a good system, but a bad system, another lack of true challenge but it could be worse.
    (2)

  7. 10-25-2013 03:11 PM