The majority of my arguments between other people were based on exactly what you just said here. And this is why I thanked you before for seeing it.
To add on to what you already said.
The majority of people who simply say "you don't need that" are taking from their point of view of them knowing and having better gear than the other person who has no clue.. However Sometimes it takes gear to obtain gear. Whether you are wearing Abyssea Perle Set or AF3, the fact is you had to have a decent set of gear allowing you to obtain better pieces because if you just head straight into areas unprepared, Winning is much harder than succeeding. Which leads to failure, wasting valuable time. That was part of the intro to my guide on how certain gear can help you explore higher areas.
While its easy to look up gear sets other people posted on FFXIAH. Gear doesn't make the skill for you. Statistics and mechanics can prove better on paper,but many things can change the overall outcome of what was being proven. Like if you try to prove someone that building a house is better than building a roof yet the person who chooses to build a roof didn't need to build a house since the roof showed to be good enough for what was being accomplished.
Some gears can teach you things other gear doesn't. You might try a haste set but then try using a fast cast set thinking they do the same exact thing only to find out something new on why the pieces are different.
I tried to explain with the example of looking at a gear set on FFXAH tends to lead people to not pay attention to small details.
Someone suggestion using Owl Eyes for Idle Refresh but they totally left out 1 important detail that makes a huge difference.
OWLEYES
[Main] All Races
DPS: 608 DMG:22 Delay:217 Damage taken +10% Adds "Refresh" effect
LV 80 WHM BLM SMN SCH GEO
What's highlighted means, you will take 10% more damage from mobs when equipping this. Which in the case if you are Taru, or have low HP and decide you need MP but ignore this detail, you just put your life in even more danger for not paying attention.
But from laziness, to having no motivation over how to overcome certain obstacles through bad experiences, people tend to give up not because they didn't try, but because they lacked the proper knowledge of accomplishing their goals effectively. Which details were included in my guide.


Reply With Quote