Results 1 to 10 of 25

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player Economizer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    1,397
    Character
    Thelaughingman
    World
    Valefor
    Main Class
    WHM Lv 99
    Quote Originally Posted by Karbuncle View Post
    Also yes, a Taru (Melee)DD is foolish. Taru are just plain awful as Melee DD. while its not going to be a huge difference, they lack any strong features in STR or DEX, and are statistically the worse Melee DD Race available. Though the gap is not WTF huge.
    I wouldn't compare a Tarutaru's STR to their DEX. They have average DEX. Their STR is below average.

    Still, a Tarutaru's STR isn't insurmountable, it is only an eleven point deficit compared to an Elvaan's STR. Basically, it won't kill you.

    What will kill you as a Tarutaru melee is the only stat that has enough difference and importance between races to matter - HP. Also, many melee players merits HP, which negates any possible fix that could have while keeping the gap as wide if not wider.

    At the widest gap you're missing 445 HP between yourself and a Galka, and this difference will get your ass killed. This wouldn't be so bad if every job had an MP pool or even every job that does have an MP pool had it make a make or break difference but the prevalence of refresh sources have made the 467 or so MP difference at the widest point (a job/subjob combination that nobody uses on a job that is arguably the most neglected job) between yourself and a Galka. There aren't any unique refresh sources to help rebalance this, and further adding insult to injury, the easiest way to start a fight with more MP is converts HP to MP gear, something a Galka can afford to do, but the opposite isn't always an option with melees without MP pools.

    Any chances of this inbalance being remotely negated are pooped on by Tarutaru's low VIT, and even Tarutaru's above average AGI or INT doesn't help since it won't make you evade enough damage enough of the time or resist enough magic damage enough of the time.

    So SE balances mobs to be threatening and deal about 370~595 more damage to be a threat to everyone who isn't a Tarutaru which is often lethal to melee range Tarutaru. The worst DD in the game is a dead one, so HP ends up actually mattering more then any other stat.

    Despite all this I suggest you choose whatever race you want and have fun. If enough Tarutaru players complain about the imbalance we could see a change in monster actions or HP/MP numbers between races.
    (2)

  2. #2
    Player RealmReborn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    8
    Character
    Kefkaru
    World
    Shiva
    Main Class
    WAR Lv 15
    Quote Originally Posted by Economizer View Post
    Despite all this I suggest you choose whatever race you want and have fun. If enough Tarutaru players complain about the imbalance we could see a change in monster actions or HP/MP numbers between races.
    Thanks for the input (both of you). ^^

    Even though I'd very much love to build a Taru tank or melee, I don't think I'll take the gamble on it. The last thing I want is to get to cap and be looked down upon because of something like this, lol. I'm so glad I saw this now instead of a few months down the road... in every other game I've played with racial stats it didn't have an impact really except for the first 10-20 levls.
    (0)