The Flame Geode Thread...... Again.

[TMG]

So, I just decided to go spend a whole Firesday in Cape Teriggan with two characters, not partied together, slaughtering everything in sight. Once the day was over, my Thief had 0 flame geodes, while my Ninja had 2 flame geodes. Is this seriously working as intended? There was no weather of any kind in effect through the whole day. The fact that treasure hunter didn't yield a single geode is a bit disheartening. I think the drop rate on the corresponding day needs to be adjusted a bit. When weather is present geodes are very common. I spent less than half of a Windsday with wind weather in Sky last night and obtained 12 breeze geodes with just one character killing (Ninja). I stayed near a zone and zoned in and out after each drop to reset the 5 minute drop timer. They were easily dropping every 1-3 mobs without treasure hunter. If I had spent the whole day farming and had wind weather the entire time I would have probably had closer to ~35 geodes by the end.

[Demon6324236]

5 minute drop timer

This needs to be removed completely no matter what is done with Flame Geodes!

[Camiie]

So, I just decided to go spend a whole Firesday in Cape Teriggan with two characters, not partied together, slaughtering everything in sight. Once the day was over, my Thief had 0 flame geodes, while my Ninja had 2 flame geodes. Is this seriously working as intended?

I'm sure it is working as intended, BUT that doesn't mean it's working as it should. I think some of us, present company excluded, often make the mistake of assuming that SE's intentions are the way things should be. I would argue that, more often than not, their intentions are dead wrong.

Not all fire based weapons are so exceptional as to warrant being harder to obtain than any other elemental type. Some are great, some are situationally useful, and some aren't worth the time it takes to do the initial trial. That's really not much different than most of the other elements though. It seems the intention was to make the best elemental weapons the hardest to obtain, which could almost be seen as reasonable, but this comes at the great expense of someone who just wants a boost to fire based spells or a more efficient Ifrit. Where's the balance in that?

[Kysaiana]

I've definitely noticed that treasure hunter seems to have no affect on geode drop rate. As for the 5 min drop timer, it doesn't exist. I've personally had geodes drop again as early as 3 min after the last one in an area with weather. There might be a minimum drop time but it's not 5 min, and it's probably just random.