Blood Pact Enhancement Stats Explained

[Karbuncle]

Premise: I'm not against what you said in this post I'm quoting or in THIS, just wanted to drop my two cents.

Good, Thats how i like it. Same rules of my first post apply too btw.

Well it does?
It increases duration.

Asked and Answered. Er well, 1 post up. I Corrected that lol. So i won't quote the rest.

When you talk about "not having enough exclusive buffs" please remember that we're soon gonna get:
1) An additional Avatar, Caith Sith (with additional BPs! :P)
2) An additional 2hr Avatar (Atomos)
3) An additional 2hr JA (just like every other job)

IDK, I don't like the idea of our uses being entirely 2hour. SCH has that problem too. As far as Cait sith buffs, I significantly doubt it'll be anything that makes the job useful, But i will hope a lot.

I don't want to say SMN is fine as it is, but in a game with 20+ jobs it's pretty clear you have to make so certain jobs are better/moreefficient than others. If you're too anal about getting all jobs being perfectly "balanced" in that regard, you run into the consequence of making all of them too similar/homogeneized.

It's bad saying this, especially when one of the jobs who's not among "the good ones" is one of your favourite, but in the long run it's a good thing for all of us.

I don't think SMN needs a Balancing, I think what it needs is to crawl out of the mediocrity it currently is. At the time being, Some jobs are Great/On the top (WAR, SAM, WHM), Some jobs are in the middle, (THF, MNK, DRK), and some jobs are just shit tier (SMN, RDM, DNC)

Those jobs in Shit tier need to be at least moved up to Mid Tier, I'm not asking them to be top tier, But mid tier. Buffing Summoner's BP:Wards will put them mid-tier, because at least then, Their buffs would be on par or comparible to other alternatives, making them not a "Well, They can do it all, but worse", but a "They seem about equal, So either or is fine". BP's are stiffed to 45 second recast, Stratagems for SCH/SCH Are on a tighter recast too. In a way, the balance system is already in place, Some of the BP's just need to be a tad more potent.

Even making Titan't stoneskin head up to about 300~ Would be a good middle ground. The Phalanx from Diabolos is what i really want buffed, and maybe some of Carbuncle's BPs.

Stratagems are on 48seconds recast after level 90.
I wish it were 30 at level 99!
I'd be fine with 48 seconds and 6 charges too probably.

How many charges do you have, was it 4 or 5?

The same thing could be said about Scholar and Embrava, and back in the days for COR and Wild Card and overall many jobs have been in such a situation over the years.
At least SMN does have a reason for other people to invite them to PTs.
What should jobs like PUP or BST say in that regard? And other jobs as well.
SMN's situation may not be as good as other jobs, but it's not as bad as others either.

You probably talked about this piece by piece, So I want to say I spelled this bellow, Its not "Whine about SCH Day" or "Whine about COR Day", its more "Whine about SMN" Day in this thread... Just because there's more than 1 job in the Shit Tier category doesn't mean it needs to stay there to keep the other shit tier jobs company.

They all need work!

Also, SMN is still a powerful job when stacked together. Think about how many things can an Alliance of 18SMNs do if they want, but even less. Look at the new Limbus bosses, currently one of the easiest/mostefficient strategy is to spam SMNs at it.

I think an Alliance of Most pet jobs can do what SMN can do, But I'd bet a BST alliance could do it better too. Even so, a Balanced Alliance of WARs and WHMs will do it better and quicker. That argument is really kinda lame, the only thing an Alliance of SMNs is good for is disposable pets, There's no fight that only an alliance of Summoner's can do, and thats where your argument would have water, if there were fights only SMNs could accomplish, But there aren't.

Any fight an Alliance of SMN's can do, An Alliance of a balance party can do better. Though I see your general point, Its just not a solid one.

Making SMN too powerful risks making SMN-stacking perhaps *too efficient*.
I'm sure SE knows this and that's why it's reluctant to buff SMN.

SMN's probably Is that it suffers from RDM Syndrome, Which you are diagnosing it with too, The fear that "If we do anything, It'll break the game" - Therefor, the job is stuck in mediocrity because of the fear it could break it. Avatars aren't horrible, and the job isn't useless per say, Its just its very subpar in all fields.

My suggestion isn't really, i guess, to buff it on par with WAR, but the whole "hateless DD" thing has really went out the window around 2007, the job needs some juice, and not just new toys that will ultimately add nothing to the job (I know I'm condemning them before i get them... but I'm not excited for Cait sith as he was described as Carbuncle 2)

IN SPITE OF THIS I think some BPs should be fixed, like I mentioned above, and I also think the following things should be fixed

1. BP recast times: 45 is too much, allow us to stack gear up to 30 seconds please. We'd still be bound by MP limits, seeing what the average MP cost for a BP is, I think it would be a good balancment making the job more efficient without making it "too strong"
2. Fix the range of Avatar's Favour. AF is currently a very underestimated and powerful buff, but with such a short range it's hard to make good use of it, so almost nobody does which is a shame. "Potency" is fine as it is for most buffs, but something needs to be done about the range imho

And I can agree with most if not all of this. However, I can personally say I'm not a fan of Avatar's Favor... Its a great buff, ad you're right, underestimated, I just wish it didn't have to nerf the summoner.

BRD Songs don't nerf the BRD
COR Rolls don't nerf the COR

I know its not a perfect comparison, but neither of them have to keep an avatar out, draining their resources, and Limiting their BP Choices, While actually having to build up buff potency to make it useful.

I just think there's far too many restrictions on Avatar's favor, I'd be happy just with the removal of the Pet Nerf to Damage, Since we already lack enough of that.

[Zhronne]

Even making Titan't stoneskin head up to about 300~ Would be a good middle ground. The Phalanx from Diabolos is what i really want buffed, and maybe some of Carbuncle's BPs.

I agree with that. Diabolos and Carbuncle Ward BPs need buffing, so does Earthen Ward.

How many charges do you have, was it 4 or 5?

Last update to stratagems comes at level 90. 5 charges, 48 seconds recast.
I was hoping for a new update at level 99 but alas nothing changed.
48 seconds is such a strange timer, makes the OCD in me unsatisfied! :P

Any fight an Alliance of SMN's can do, An Alliance of a balance party can do better. Though I see your general point, Its just not a solid one.

I see what you mean there.
About army of BSTs being better than SMN uh... I dunno. Guess it depends on the fight. BST pets are stronger as in they have more HP/defense/stats, but you also consume items which have a gil cost to summon them and to heal them, with SMN you just use a rechargeable resource (MP) to summon them as much as you want. Also, BP Rage from Avatars are usually much more powerful and spammable than Pet's TP moves.
I guess it depends on the kind of mob you're fighting of course, but overall I can agree with your statement.
I don't agree with the "anything an army of SMN can do, a normal alliance can do better". It's true for some fights, maybe the majority of fights, but it's not true for the kind of fights I was thinking of, for example the two new Limbus fights, where a small PTs of SMN has it much easier than a small (or even larger) pt with a normal setup.
Those mobs have very powerful AoE (or insta-death) which can be really dangerous for players or for pets, while SMNs do not have to worry about sacrificing their avatars.

And I can agree with most if not all of this. However, I can personally say I'm not a fan of Avatar's Favor... Its a great buff, ad you're right, underestimated, I just wish it didn't have to nerf the summoner.

BRD Songs don't nerf the BRD
COR Rolls don't nerf the COR

I know its not a perfect comparison, but neither of them have to keep an avatar out, draining their resources, and Limiting their BP Choices, While actually having to build up buff potency to make it useful.

Eh... it's hard to draw a balance line here.
I mean, Avatar's Favor needs to have a con, otherwise we would all keep it up 100% of the time, right?
It should be a situational thing.
Problem is that atm it's something NOBODY uses, despite the fact that in theory some of those buffs are pretty powerful. I think about Ramuh's critical rate or Ifrit's +24% DA, those are crazy buffs, up to the point it makes me wonder if those are real numbers or if someone played a nice trolling trick updating Wiki page.

AF was a good idea to promote among players a playstyle involving us to keep our avatars out instead of constantly summoning/dismissing our pets (which was the typical playstyle when they added AF), still *something* has to be done about it.
What? I have no clue. Increasing the range from 10yalms to 20yalms would be a good starting point I think.

As for the reduced stats on Avatar once you activate AF I think that honestly they have a lower impact than most people want to make it look like, or is it just me being completely wrong here?
Fighting less powerful stuff I hardly even notice it tbh, whereas on the tougher mobs of course you can clearly see it.

[Dantedmc]

I mean, Avatar's Favor needs to have a con, otherwise we would all keep it up 100% of the time, right?

Why? look at afflatus: solace, no cons at all. I honestly feel AF should have just been a JT instead of JA (with no penalties of course). I think SMN needs a few changes to work better in a party.

General
-Lower the BP Cap to 12 seconds (-80%) in line with Fast Cast, Haste, and Recast caps
-Increase Avatar melee damage and possibly BP damage
-Enhance many of the ward BPs' potency

Favor Related
-Remove the negative penalties from avatar's favor
-Remove the charge up from favor, the favor should always be at full potency. My reasoning for is that it's one buff not 2+ like brd and cor.
-Change Titan's favor to pdt
-Change Fenrir' favor to mdt or mdb
-Increase the potency of Carby's favor and possibly Shiva's Favor

New Stances
-One new stance that increases BP damage
-One new stance that enhances Avatar's Favors in some way

I feel like these changes would further enhances SMN's roles as a buffer and magic DD.