On the topic of DRG being busy and button bloat.

[MikoRemi]

Make it so combos switch to the next combo series like it does in PvP. The mechanic is there so why not use it?

To be honest, I do wish the combos became more like PVP in the sense of for say; Warrior having two buttons dedicated to the Storm's Eye and the Storm's Path combos respectively. Nobody would ever hit the wrong combo button intentionally so having it be simplified avoids this issue...however there is a catch.

If they did simplify it so that the basic combos themselves simply can't be messed up(other than hitting the other combo during the finisher but you'll still at least get the effect), they'll have to consider many factors, such as making positionals matter more or adding some kind of actual effects, maybe for the Warrior example they could get a Butcher's Block combo to have some other effect even, and adding more actual buttons to compensate for the lack of buttons. Meanwhile for jobs that have actual button bloat like say, Black Mage, Samurai, and Machinist as some examples, actually fix the button bloat(Samurai; Ikishoten turning into Ogi Namikiri, Black Mage; Ley Lines becoming Between the Lines along with Fire IV/Blizzard IV and Freeze/Flare swapping depending on your element, Machinist; Hypercharge turning into Heat Blast and Spread Shot/Scattergun turning into Auto Crossbow during Hypercharge status) and go from there.

The thing I would be worried about is adding the PVP combo system but not adding anything else which would simplify gameplay but not add anything to the space left. And seeing how things have been going lately, I worry that is what they would do even if the actual idea wouldn't be so bad if executed properly...

[ZiraZ]

Make it so combos switch to the next combo series like it does in PvP. The mechanic is there so why not use it?

Because that's lame and boring in a PvE setting.
It's only ok in pvp because pvp in this game is very quick and burst windows lasts seconds.

[Aco505]

I have submitted a post in the bug forums in hopes that they will notice and do something about it (https://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/...58#post5928458).

They put the post under "working as intended" so I suppose we're stuck with this until they decide to change it. The best solution would be to just revert the change back to 6.08 where both HJ and MD were separate, although reducing the grace period to 0.8s would be fine I suppose.

Until they finish their campaign to autocrit anything higher than 1000 potency; Then DRG will be wanted in fewer groups for 2 reasons.

If an attack has 100% direct hit/crit chance, it should get a damage boost (usually 5%, with the exception of some BRD/DNC outliers) if it's used under the effect of a direct hit/crit chance buff, and the problem of crit synergy is solved. I fear though that they might just homogenize these buffs into flat % damage increasing ones...

Again, to reiterate, make the string build to the payoff, not pay it off in the middle then make the end lame.

Hmmmm perhaps if we had a 4-GCD string and the positional (only one, like between levels 58 and 64) hit harder, but I think the current iteration is the best, despite the damage curve. My only gripe is Litany's duration. It should be 20s for the DRG and 15s for the party so that we can have more wiggle room. We'd still want to fit everything into 15s buffs, but at least we wouldn't be as pressured to use the first Nastrond right after using BL.

The thing I would be worried about is adding the PVP combo system but not adding anything else which would simplify gameplay but not add anything to the space left.

Because that's lame and boring in a PvE setting.
It's only ok in pvp because pvp in this game is very quick and burst windows lasts seconds.

Exactly, without any payoff it'd be boring. I personally like our combo string. If they really want to consolidate buttons, they should merge Lance Charge and Dragon Sight, and, despite the fact that I don't really like it, the positionals with Heavens' Thrust and Chaotic Spring or themselves.

I'd like them to allow for the freestyle positional option, in which you choose which one comes out first after HT/CS, but if they also made it so that after using one of these two, they turned into Fang and Claw and Wheeling Thrust respectively, you'd have both extra positional freedom and two extra buttons (three with the LC + DS merge). The other option would be having the positionals share the same button since one can never be used while the other is available, but we wouldn't be able to freestyle them then.

I'm too used to FnC and WT the way they are now and would prefer if they stayed that way, but I'd rather make this small adjustment than lose parts of our kit for nothing.

If they're gonna remove or change anything, it has to be because something else is put on top, not just to prune. They should do the rework on 7.0, not in the middle of the expansion...

[YukiB]

they should merge Lance Charge and Dragon Sight

I had the same thought. Turn Dragon Sight into a toggle like Dance Partner, that can be placed on another player outside of combat. Then, every time you use Lance Charge, it gives a small damage buff to your Dragon Sight partner too. No more having to target (or macro) Dragon Sight in the middle of combat, and you get to keep the cool tether animation.

But that would be a group buff on a 60s cooldown, and you know we can't have those anymore!

[Aco505]

I had the same thought. Turn Dragon Sight into a toggle like Dance Partner, that can be placed on another player outside of combat. Then, every time you use Lance Charge, it gives a small damage buff to your Dragon Sight partner too. No more having to target (or macro) Dragon Sight in the middle of combat, and you get to keep the cool tether animation.

But that would be a group buff on a 60s cooldown, and you know we can't have those anymore!

I'd just rather make Dragon Sight an upgrade to Lance Charge, with the former giving like 15-20% damage for 20s on a 60s cooldown. Dragon Sight lost all of its flavor when the tether was removed and it's just something we press and forget every 2 minutes without any extra implications, unlike abilities like Brotherhood or Arcane Circle. If they made DS like that, then it'd be better though!

[LeonKeyh]

I'd just rather make Dragon Sight an upgrade to Lance Charge, with the former giving like 15-20% damage for 20s on a 60s cooldown. Dragon Sight lost all of its flavor when the tether was removed and it's just something we press and forget every 2 minutes without any extra implications, unlike abilities like Brotherhood or Arcane Circle. If they made DS like that, then it'd be better though!

The tether being removed didn't really change THAT much. Just got rid of a somewhat annoying aspect of the ability that made it worse than similar abilities. The on instance that the tether mattered really was if you threw it on a ranged and a BLM isn't going to move out of Ley lines for the tether, and SMN and RDM can easily just move in and stand a little closer.

I agree with the post your replied to. Make "Dragon Sight" a Dance Partner style buff that grants them 5% damage whenever Lance Charge is used.

[Aco505]

The tether being removed didn't really change THAT much. Just got rid of a somewhat annoying aspect of the ability that made it worse than similar abilities. The on instance that the tether mattered really was if you threw it on a ranged and a BLM isn't going to move out of Ley lines for the tether, and SMN and RDM can easily just move in and stand a little closer.

I agree with the post your replied to. Make "Dragon Sight" a Dance Partner style buff that grants them 5% damage whenever Lance Charge is used.

The range change was good mechanically (and very needed), but the ability lost its "flavor" with it gone. SCH's tether retains the animation despite the range, but we lost it, why? I just find it lackluster now and, while I don't want them to change anything, I'd rather modify Dragon Sight than prune damage oGCDs myself.

[Jirah]

Just a excuse to remove its jumps or it’s dot rotation