Scholar is my main since the beginning and I have to agree, it's just awful for so many reasons. I'm just stopping Sch right now, and I'll go for another healer, hoping they'll fix it.

Problems :

- Absolutely no gameplay at all compared to all the other jobs
- Aetherflow is a pain and very frustrating, can't use it if not in fight, and also can't use it when other members are in fight.
You have to deal damage or heal someone/ do another action before you can use it...
- And it doesn't have the -5sec cooldown for each time you use Lustrate anymore
- And then if Aetherflow comes back and you still have some stacks you HAVE TO use it even if everyone are full HP, to fill the fairy gauge... since we don't have Energy Drain anymore.
This is so stupid and frustrating...
- And then the fairy... we don't see her so we don't know what to do, her skills are definitely not "instant" cause of the animation, and it feels it slow us down instead of helping.
- Helping dps in dungeon is ultra boring, no dot spread or this kind of thing
- Everything that made scholar different and enjoyable is gone.
- And since the ability in our hotbar isn't the ability of the fairy, we have to go to the menu to look at the description.......Really? Like everyone is saying, Someone played it at some point ?
- And the Super fairy has almost the same ablities than eos so once again, boring shortcut...

Idea of gameplay (You should) :

- Put back Aetherflow how it was.

- Give back Energy drain (So we can fill our fairy bar, without throwing useless lustrate)

- Put back Selene with different actions
- An action reducing a bit cooldown of caster(s), an action reducing a bit cooldown for melee(s))
- All the fairy actions are on different cooldowns, but Summonnig another fairy costs 2 aether flow (for example), and the 'reducing cooldown melee' action is an aoe that doesn't stack with the 'reduction cooldown of caster action'. So we have to manage placement of the fairy, and give us a gameplay to play with.

- Of course make the fairy more visible.

- Make the fairy actions more instant.

- Put an aoe damage buff on Seraph (even 1 or 2% is fine), so we have an objective, and feel more usefull.