I was quite upset about this issue. Very upset in fact, and I was all set to go on an internet rampage through the forum, but I won't and I will just give a warning to anyone with multiple character options to be very careful before I move on from FFXIV for good.
I had two character options with the same name just different servers since the game was free and when I started I wanted to check out different servers to see what they were like. Anyway after being booted last night as subs started I got my money together today and went to reactivate. Long story short, after reactivating and thinking I was all set to play I found out I reactivated the wrong character option by mistake. I immediately felt like a complete idiot and couldn't believe that had happened, but surely SE could fix the problem and I could go on happily right? Wrong.
Contacted support, and apparently there is no way to reverse the issue or even so much as just swap the options so I was told (though I'm not sure how much I believe that). Thought it was pretty weird really, I mean what if there is an unauthorized renewal? The person is just out of luck? SE doesn't even have the ability to deactivate one character option and activate a different one on a person's account?
I have no one to blame though but myself, if I had paid more attention I wouldn't have made the mistake and it wouldn't even be an issue, but that's all it was, a mistake. Everyone makes mistakes including SE (see: FFXIV) so I thought they of all people would be more forgiving in a situation like this for someone actually trying to support this game through these hard times. Not say my only option is to pay another $9 for the character option I wanted the first time (since I had subbed for 3 months).
What do they care though, they already have my money for 3 months. I will bite that bullet I suppose, but I won't be supporting FFXIV any longer or SE period for that matter. I was ready to fight the good fight all the way up to 2.0 and beyond as I had been doing for a while now, but I'm too disappointed after that.
Anyway just letting everyone know my experience so that they can know to check, double check, triple check, etc. which option they choose upon reactivating should they need to in the future since there is no going back after.
I wish FFXIV all the best and hope it crushes the competition when 2.0 hits. It definitely has the potential. Alright now I'll get out of everyone's hair and get back to Skyrim.