Not sure why people are still arguing, a GM response was posted in page 3 http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...28#post2358628 if someone is preventing the party to finish the duty by not fulfilling their role they can be voted to be dismissed, there's no "if i can enter the content i have the right to be there", it's a group content after all, not solo content, so OP, if this scenario ever appears, you're free to vote dismiss, just don't be too hasty and give them a few chances (like you did).