Where Is The Logic Banning New Characters For Existing Accounts on Congested Server?

From the "Congested Server" web page:

"New characters cannot be created on Congested Worlds."

So:

1) I have an account and I have a character on it that I can log in.
2) I can only play one character on the account at a time
3) If I log out of a character that exists I can log into another one that exists
4) If I log out of a character SE ban me from creating a new character on a 'congested' server.
5) SE define congestion as the number of PLAYERS actively playing, which is totally unrelated to them logging into an existing character OR creating a new one.

So explain to me SE why this ridiculous banning of existing players being able to create a new character on a server they already HAVE characters on.

It's not banning it's closing the servers the ones that are higher congested will give priority to the actual players themselves. Also most of those congested servers you have to wait for OFF peak hours and you will then be able to create a character.

Not sure if bait but…

I don’t know what to tell you. Active players are logged into the server which has a limit to how often it can let people in and how many people it can have running around at once. As well as they want to spread people out because they have a limit to how many characters can be created in a world at once. Like just make a new character in an unpopulated world, it’s not that big of a deal since you can interact with everyone and do anything through PF and once things have died down just a minor queue to get over to another world to do stuff like maps.

Also “banning” makes it sound a lot worse than it is. “Restricting” is a lot better.

No logic. There you go

Potential reason 1: It prevents potential increased log in. Instead of logging in for 1 hour on 1 character, a player might log in for 2 hours on 2 characters, etc.

Potential reason 2: Blocking new characters on a congested world means there are more names for existing characters to choose from.

As other have said there is no ban. If you want to create a character on a specific world to play with friends, you may want to start checking early am (like 4-6 am where the majority of the player base of that world is located). Some worlds might still be congested at those hours but it is much better now than it was a month ago.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pintsized

From the "Congested Server" web page:

"New characters cannot be created on Congested Worlds."

So:

1) I have an account and I have a character on it that I can log in.
2) I can only play one character on the account at a time
3) If I log out of a character that exists I can log into another one that exists
4) If I log out of a character SE ban me from creating a new character on a 'congested' server.
5) SE define congestion as the number of PLAYERS actively playing, which is totally unrelated to them logging into an existing character OR creating a new one.

So explain to me SE why this ridiculous banning of existing players being able to create a new character on a server they already HAVE characters on.

---

There's not a particular logic to it, it's just system limitations.

Like how a character can get returner status even if you've been actively playing a separate characters, and how SE has to go to great lengths to make certain cosmetics account-wide, and so on. In a lot of ways, characters are kind of a pseudo-separate-account.

Someone at SE might have went "Yeah logically a person can only log in one character at a time so there's no reason to restrict character creation when they already have one on that server"; their system simply can't distinguish that this is the case vs someone with no characters there.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by linayar

Potential reason 2: Blocking new characters on a congested world means there are more names for existing characters to choose from.

---

uhhh what? Existing characters already have names.... they don't need more variety to choose from

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wereotter

uhhh what? Existing characters already have names.... they don't need more variety to choose from

---

They can always change their names; especially as other people delete or move their characters from the server.

The logic is likely that they just didn't design granular control over char creation limits.

It's just on or off.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkyrie_Lenneth

The logic is likely that they just didn't design granular control over char creation limits.

It's just on or off.

---

They don't need to. They just need a hard limit per world and include 8 slots per account as allowed by the standard subscription in that limit.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Toutatis

As other have said there is no ban. If you want to create a character on a specific world to play with friends, you may want to start checking early am (like 4-6 am where the majority of the player base of that world is located). Some worlds might still be congested at those hours but it is much better now than it was a month ago.

---

This actually won't work for world servers that are designated as "Congested" worlds. It is not possible to create characters on those worlds at any time, until SE actively removes the "Congested" designation.

Other worlds might temporarily step in and out of the "Creation of New Characters Unavailable" status, because that status is dynamically assigned and removed based on live login counts. In this case, the above advice (creating a character in off-peak hours) will work.

If a world is marked as "Congested", however, it is blocked from all new characters until SE decides to reverse the decision, which is usually re-evaluated and applied in the next patch.

Just another over site from either 1.0 or 2.0 team. That is probably to much work to fix, but everyone has known it is wrong since 2.0. Just have to use one of the work arounds. We need a FF17 that has taken into account these weird little overlooked issues. It is not game breaking. Just a general QoL that should have been included from the start.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EorzeaWanderer

This actually won't work for world servers that are designated as "Congested" worlds. It is not possible to create characters on those worlds at any time, until SE actively removes the "Congested" designation.

Other worlds might temporarily step in and out of the "Creation of New Characters Unavailable" status, because that status is dynamically assigned and removed based on live login counts. In this case, the above advice (creating a character in off-peak hours) will work.

If a world is marked as "Congested", however, it is blocked from all new characters until SE decides to reverse the decision, which is usually re-evaluted and applied in the next patch.

---

For years Balmung was designated as Congested. However, around 4am you could create a new character. Congestion is based on currently logged in characters. If your server is so busy that at all times there is a number of players logged in, then yes you can never create a character. However, the congested tag does disappear if the number of people logged in is below the predetermined log in amount. Best place to watch if it opens is https://arrstatus.com/
it auto refreshes and will let you use notifications when a server opens up.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DragonFlyy

For years Balmung was designated as Congested. However, around 4am you could create a new character. Congestion is based on currently logged in characters. If your server is so busy that at all times there is a number of players logged in, then yes you can never create a character. However, the congested tag does disappear if the number of people logged in is below the predetermined log in amount. Best place to watch if it opens is https://arrstatus.com/
it auto refreshes and will let you use notifications when a server opens up.

---

No, big C Congested means it's completely locked from all characters until they remove that during maint. There were tons of posts here how Balmung being congested killed the server community cuz no new blood.


There are 2 types of server char locks.

Soft locks that update duri g the day, and hard locks that are applied during maint. Hard locks are always accompanied by a lodestone post.

https://na.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodes...a5f0c567b12427