[Deleted]
Move along nothing to see here. It was a dumb idea. I'm embarrassed I shared it.
Fun Discussion: Add-On/Expansion of the current Races
Printable View
-
02-15-2016, 04:38 PMDefiasFun Discussion: Add-On/Expansion of the current Races
-
02-15-2016, 04:43 PMRyuRoots
These ideas are terrible. Miqo'te are feline by nature, making some bizarre canine/lupine variant is ridiculous. The Roegadyn do not need tails. If you want the Galka, go play FFXI. We don't need bad fanfic additional body parts. We just need a character creater that doesn't inexplicably block off a ton of options arbitrarily based on race, gender, or even face preset in some cases (such as specific scar patterns).
-
02-15-2016, 05:01 PMWellFooled
Its far too late to make such a major change to the races. If a patch were focused on more customization within the races, I would be perfectly content with more options for what is already there (face, nose, eye, and body shapes, scars, tattoos, ear shapes for Elezen, tails for Miqo'te, etc, etc). Turning Roes into fish people and Miqo'te into any furry animal that's ever existed is too much of a change for the lore that has been established for more than six years and its a change I wouldn't welcome.
-
02-15-2016, 05:10 PMLadyVal
They already have concepts for a canine-based, and leporine-based race. :)
http://livedoor.blogimg.jp/umadori07...7/c75087f8.jpg
http://livedoor.blogimg.jp/umadori07...a/6afe7ee1.jpg
http://cdn4.dualshockers.com/wp-cont.../04/Viera1.jpg
http://cdn4.dualshockers.com/wp-cont.../04/Viera2.jpg -
02-15-2016, 05:49 PMAskaRay
If I could addon to Miqo'te I'd give more lore for Keepers in-game.
Maybe a named non-evil male Keeper? Yeah?
....that counts, right? -
02-15-2016, 06:10 PMAshkendorRaccoons do not belong to the order Rodentia. They aren't rodents. Aside from that... no. Just... no. It seems like you basically want to mush up Au Ra and Roegadyn into a weird hybrid and I don't even understand why Miqo'te would suddenly be bunnies/dogs.Quote:
Originally Posted by Defias
When people say they want more options for the current races, we're talking about things like facial features, hairstyles, and scars. -
02-15-2016, 07:17 PMDgsoilHaven't been keeping up on all my FFXIV news for awhile because I have been taking a semi-break from playing it outside of raiding for awhile now (whereas once I gobbled up every bit and byte of news I could find), but when did they show this? I know it's from the FATE in Tokyo thing but I don't remember them ever showing this on the forums with a Q&A type thing like they usually do. I love my kitty, but I swear to whatever deity that canine race would worship I would race switch so fast and leave C'desh in a box out in the rain to be that.Quote:
Originally Posted by LadyVal
-
02-15-2016, 07:28 PMBrokenFox
Can't wait to play as a Frog'ote
-
02-15-2016, 07:32 PMTheodric
I actually don't want any new playable races until the existing races have their options expanded. By that, however, I mean expanded in a reasonable manner - they don't need to suddenly get all sorts of weird traits. We just need new base faces and a variety of new scars/facial features. I'd happily play a male Highlander, for example, if they could have proper eyebrows and had more classically handsome facial options.
One of the biggest issues with new playable races is that every piece of gear in the game needs to be adjusted to fit them. I'd rather see that development time spent elsewhere. -
02-15-2016, 07:44 PMDefias
I apologize...I forgot that people can't have fun on these forums.
I also forgot that it's a venial sin to suggest anything.
The whole concept that obviously was missed is...IF you could and it would RETCON the racial Lore so it would make sense.
Yoshida even said that we won't get Veira or similar races because they would be Miq'ote but with bunny features.
Which made me think...why not just make Miq'ote into an animal race?
I apologize for wanting to have a for fun conversation. -
02-15-2016, 07:50 PMWellFooledTake it easy there Defias. Nothing wrong with making suggestions, but you have to be prepared for people to disagree. You asked in your post "Thoughts opinions? Would you like my changes?" and people answered. Some of us maybe a little too truthfully, but that's the nature of discussions.Quote:
Originally Posted by Defias
-
02-15-2016, 07:55 PMRyuRootsBeing passive-aggressive and saying everyone just hates fun for not liking your ideas doesn't exactly endear you or your ideas to anyone. No one here misunderstood the premise, either. We just don't care for the ideas. It is not some attack on you personally.Quote:
Originally Posted by Defias
-
02-15-2016, 07:59 PMDefias
I am ready for some backlash. But folks obviously ignored the OP, and took pot shots without even attempting to respond to the topic.
If you dislike my ideas. That is fine...you don't have to like it...so tell me What is YOUR idea?
What would YOU change/addon?
Or in other words...at least contribute.
(The word You is a generalization. I am not directly aiming it at you WellFooled.)
It gets frustrating when myself (and others) try to make a fun topic and we get blasted into oblivion.
Then people turn around and say these forums are filled with negativity.
In game I have friends who often say: "It'd be great to have a tail again.", "My only complaint...we're really all rehashed of FFXIV races.", "Wish we had gotten Veira and not Au'Ra."
"Veira wouldn't work. They'd be Miq'ote clones."
Which is what spawned this topic.
I'm not posting a: Change the races. I hate them topic. Or complaining.
Honestly...this community tends to attack people rather frequently.
Aggression is often the only way to get a point across and/or nip things in the bud.
That said I am legitimately sorry I posted. I feel like an idiot for sharing. -
02-15-2016, 08:08 PMRyuRootsMy idea is this:Quote:
Originally Posted by Defias
or if you're asking what my idea for a new race is: don't have one. I'm not an artist or a game designer. Not my job. Though I don't see how just functionally adding in the viera but saying they're "sub-race options for Seekers" is any different than simply adding them (which I am not in favor of). I don't know exactly what persecution complex you have, but you're not being "blasted into oblivion". You asked for feedback and are getting feedback. If you don't like the answers you get, then oh well. Making baseless accusations about what people read or understand also doesn't help your case.Quote:
Originally Posted by Theodric
-
02-15-2016, 09:51 PMSynrin
The thing is that, from what I've seen, it looks more like mutilating rather than fun. Kind of like if you went to some random forum that deals with real life and started a discussion along the lines wouldn't it be cool to put lizard tails on humans? I mean, ok, that is a bit of a cool idea, but I think I'd rather keep tails on lizards than humans.
They will probably introduce new races with certain features you might have mentioned because after all, this is a fantasy.
Now whether they should make new races or work on the existing ones is for another discussion that is going on atm.
EDIT: If you want to play a race with a tail, choose a race with a tail. I like elven ears but I don't think I'd add them on my Au Ra. Just doesn't fit. Tails don't fit Roes either. -
02-15-2016, 10:03 PMBalmung_GriffinHoly sh.., that's Kelger! I would switch in a flash. Always wanted a race that looked more beast than human.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dgsoil
-
02-16-2016, 07:16 PMLadyValThese were shown around the same time as Viera I believe, and it was explained that both viera and this canine race were left for later and Au'Ra were used because both the Viera and canine models would need a lot of extra work to get leg and foot gear to fit them properly since they have non-human feet and leg shapes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dgsoil