As it currently stands, WAR just isn't accepted as MT for certain encounters (mainly T9). I think the reason for this, is their lack of burst mitigation. While I have both WAR and PLD at i110, I enjoy playing WAR much more than I do PLD, and I can understand why this can be discouraging to players that only have WAR as their main job. Here are some minor changes that I think would help WAR as job:
1. Rampart: Allowing WAR to cross-class Rampart from Gladiator would help tremendously. To compensate, they would remove Awareness from our list of cross-class abilites. Currently, PLD can take foresight from Marauder, but WAR can't take PLD's small defensive CD, Rampart.
2. Holmgang: Compared to PLD's Hallowed Ground, this ability falls WAY short. My proposal to making this ability much more viable, would be to have it lock you at 25%-30% of your maximum HP, rather than 1 HP. Of course to compensate, they would increase the CD of the ability to 5 minutes, instead of 3. With Homlgang leaving you only at 1 HP, it's very hard for healers to respond quick enough to save you from death, making this ability very unreliable, and most times, not worth even using.
3. Bloodbath: I feel like this ability could really use a buff. In it's current state, it's not very effective, even as a small CD. In single-target situations, you'll be lucky to heal more than 800 HP throughout it's 30 second duration. That's less than cross-classed Second Wind. I propose they increase the healing to 35% of damage dealt, and increase the CD to 2 minutes, from 1.5 minutes.
4. Berserk: This ability is completely fine, minus one minor detail. For the love of god, please remove the Pacification effect from the end of this ability! Why is it even there to begin with? Sometimes I have to refrain from using this ability, just so i'll be able to time my Inner Beast correctly, or pick up an add when I need to. Nothing sucks worse than wiping your group because you popped one of your cooldowns.
I'm sure some of you will disagree with my propositions, and that's fine. Discuss, revise, correct me, insult me. The choice is yours. Thanks for the read.
Minor WAR changes that I, personally, would love to see.
Printable View
-
09-20-2014, 11:14 PMRaxionMinor WAR changes that I, personally, would love to see.
-
09-20-2014, 11:26 PMWyrmnus
I personally miss the ORIGINAL Berserk, for when WAR isn't tanking. You know what I mean, right? ;)
-
09-20-2014, 11:43 PMRaxionNot sure I follow. The wink threw me off even more.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wyrmnus
-
09-20-2014, 11:59 PMWyrmnusSorry. I was referring to FFXI's Berserk.Quote:
Originally Posted by Raxion
-
09-21-2014, 12:03 AMRaxionI see. I didn't like WAR in FFXI. Too plain and slow-paced for my liking. I played BLU.Quote:
Originally Posted by Wyrmnus
-
09-21-2014, 12:05 AMLunarEmerald
Hallowed Ground is the reason people don't want warrior as a mt in t9. So they can safely take the third behemoth's favor. So, all they need to do is make holmgang better.
-
09-21-2014, 12:06 AMLunarEmerald
* Bahamut's
-
09-21-2014, 01:10 AMRaxionMuch better. At it's current, Holmgang is all but useless. It might save you in certain clutch situations, but more times than not, you just instantly die when the ability expires. WAR really needs an "oh shit" button like PLDs have. Holmgang sounds good on paper, but in practice, it's extremely lackluster. The self-root pretty much destroys the fact that it has a short CD. Rooting yourself in a bad spot is usually worse than just leaving your life in your healer's hands.Quote:
Originally Posted by LunarEmerald
If the target I use holmgang on is immune to the root effect, I shouldn't be rooted by the ability either, I think. -
09-21-2014, 01:26 AMSapphicWell if healers cant lustrate/bene or even a cure 2/adlo in 6 seconds, aint Holmgang thats the problem ^_^Quote:
Originally Posted by Raxion
-
09-21-2014, 01:28 AMkyuvenPersonally I think THIS is the crux of the argument in favor of changing it. What good is an "oh shit" button if the target's immune to it?Quote:
Originally Posted by Raxion