Poor Designed Weapon's.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GabbaGabba

It is this sense of entitlement that bothers me. Developers are doing a job. They don't owe us anything nor do we owe them anything. I understand that you don't like how they look and I'm o.k with that. I can agree to disagree. but you're basically trying to tell Picasso to use a crayon rather than a paintbrush because you feel like it would look better.

Me, also being a developer, see my work as art. I'm not bothered if people don't like the concept or how it looks, that's part of criticism, but for people to try and tell me what is best for me and my company is offensive.

I'm fine with your opinion of how they look. Just don't go up in arms trying to force them to change it after they put a lot of time and effort into designing and developing the weapons. Not unless you're the lead developer of course, then you can do what you want.

---

Considering we purchase said product and they have allowed us to give our own input on the direction via these forums, I think it's fair to voice our views on whether or not we like something.
They do owe us a good game as they have promised with the change of development.

I, as someone who studies art, feel like I should be able to voice my opinions and views with how the art direction might effect the game overall. I'm not saying that I know what's best for the company, but people needn't be chastised for suggesting a certain direction might not be best for the game or the company. We should be able to discuss these things freely and maturely without someone telling us we're simply not allowed to talk about it.

Artistic continuity is important in any piece of entertainment. I'm mostly okay with these because they make sense contextually. Gear made from the bones and horns of a fiery primal are bound to look organic and fiery. It's just a little odd against the rest of the equipment we already have.

It's rather funny, because... For all the people that have the delusion that these new Primal Weapons don't fit with the game, have a point.. Right now. And in another 6 months we will probably see a lot more armor and weapons like this while slowly losing the old bland weapon and armor sets. So in short, in a year or so, none of this will matter. Everything will be exaggerated and glowy.

PS: I like the looks of the weapons, albiet the Pugilist weapons should have been more like gauntlets with horns.

The weapons look fine to me, and certainly fit considering their origins. Their size isn't an issue either. Fantasy, final or otherwise is well known for unrealistic weapons and armors.

As to the notion that aesthetics aren't a matter of opinion, pure idiocy. This whole topic is purely a subjective matter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AlexNiculaie

The weapons look fine to me, and certainly fit considering their origins. Their size isn't an issue either. Fantasy, final or otherwise is well known for unrealistic weapons and armors.

As to the notion that aesthetics aren't a matter of opinion, pure idiocy. This whole topic is purely a subjective matter.

---

yes it is.
i wonder what the japanese forums are saying about the weapons.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kopuno

It's rather funny, because... For all the people that have the delusion that these new Primal Weapons don't fit with the game, have a point.. Right now. And in another 6 months we will probably see a lot more armor and weapons like this while slowly losing the old bland weapon and armor sets. So in short, in a year or so, none of this will matter. Everything will be exaggerated and glowy.

PS: I like the looks of the weapons, albiet the Pugilist weapons should have been more like gauntlets with horns.

---

I suppose you have a point. When more primal battles come out, more organic weapons will be introduced and it will feel more like the weapons make sense as a specialized brand from the old gods.

But do not call the regular weapons bland.
They OOZE class.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dreadnought

THAAAANK YOOUUU
and cotton candy pink robes.... oh wait they took care of that dire issue XD

you see i personally thought the cotton candy pink robes stuck out like a sore thumb and could not stand the site of them. however, i knew i had no control over their existance.
i just felt that tone of pink was wrong for the game.

---

lol thats the same thing that made me not want to use Abyssea equipment (those pink berets and gloves) in XI. At least here we have somewhat of a choice in what colors we can wear.

Weapons you get from ifrit look like there monster hunter weapons.
Seems sorta fine to me.

We need the level cap raised. I want to see more flasher gear.

Level 1-50 should be bland, poor mans gear.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Venat

Weapons you get from ifrit look like there monster hunter weapons.
Seems sorta fine to me.

We need the level cap raised. I want to see more flasher gear.

Level 1-50 should be bland, poor mans gear.

---

this i can totally agree with.

also remember people, the class specific gear is coming out. the BLM gear looks nothing like anything else in the game, its viewable in model viewers, ive seen it myself, your all gonna hate it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dreadnought

this i can totally agree with.

also remember people, the class specific gear is coming out. the BLM gear looks nothing like anything else in the game, its viewable in model viewers, ive seen it myself, your all gonna hate it.

---

pics or never happened

Yeah and what about that Dragoon armor too! That's the most unique armor in the game as of yet (not even the other artifact/job/relic/whatever) armor are similar to it...and I can't wait!