Any research into WAR DEX?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by C-croft

...

---

It would be highly illogical that SE would only add a hidden modifier on a single job out of the 9 jobs in the game, and only DEX when it comes to parry rate. You can't make any sort of statement from the data he's posted so far because the sample size isn't nearly big enough. The margin of error is too wide to make any significant guesses as to how much it's affecting the parry rate. There are also other factors that could be involved. The limited parry rate testing that was posted from Valk-Dancing mad lacked information on whether they tested just parry w/o a shield on the PLD. From what I understand the test was done for Shield Blocks specifically but because they had the data they included parries as well. We don't know the priority of Parry vs Shield. Maybe both PLD and WAR gain the same boost from DEX for parry but because Shield Blocks are checked first you won't see as many parries on a PLD.

For the record, I'm not saying OP is wrong or that his test is pointless. I'm saying if he really believes this as a possibility he needs to do extensive testing before posting any results. Wide-eyed enthusiasm after a few short trials only helps to spread misinformation about whatever it is we're missing about WAR. Frankly I'm convinced the "more research" comment was a backhanded way of saying "We don't know what's wrong either so you guys figure it out". I would rather keep my hopes low and be proven wrong than keep my hopes up only to have them come crashing down.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CurlyBruce

It would be highly illogical that SE would only add a hidden modifier on a single job out of the 9 jobs in the game, and only DEX when it comes to parry rate. You can't make any sort of statement from the data he's posted so far because the sample size isn't nearly big enough. The margin of error is too wide to make any significant guesses as to how much it's affecting the parry rate. There are also other factors that could be involved. The limited parry rate testing that was posted from Valk-Dancing mad lacked information on whether they tested just parry w/o a shield on the PLD. From what I understand the test was done for Shield Blocks specifically but because they had the data they included parries as well. We don't know the priority of Parry vs Shield. Maybe both PLD and WAR gain the same boost from DEX for parry but because Shield Blocks are checked first you won't see as many parries on a PLD.

For the record, I'm not saying OP is wrong or that his test is pointless. I'm saying if he really believes this as a possibility he needs to do extensive testing before posting any results. Wide-eyed enthusiasm after a few short trials only helps to spread misinformation about whatever it is we're missing about WAR. Frankly I'm convinced the "more research" comment was a backhanded way of saying "We don't know what's wrong either so you guys figure it out". I would rather keep my hopes low and be proven wrong than keep my hopes up only to have them come crashing down.

---

We're going down the rabbit hole here. According to the data for PLD, the stacking of DEX would have shown a massive improvement with or without blocking. But we have both agreed at this point OPs sample size IS too small.

And illogical is the new logical when it comes to FFXIV. Anyone can see that WAR isn't where it should be on the tanking ladder at this point in time. But I feel the same as you and would rather not come crashing down.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by C-croft

According to the data for PLD, the stacking of DEX would have shown a massive improvement with or without blocking.

---

The point I was making about that is if Shield Blocks have a specific cap, where as Parry has a higher cap, and Shield Blocks are checked first. The increase to Parry from DEX would seem smaller because Shield Blocks are obscuring the data. Say Shield Block is 25% rate but with the same DEX you have a 50% parry rate. You have to fail the shield check first before a parry goes off, and because you can't shield block and parry on the same attack any attack that passes the shield check will register as a block instead of a parry. So your observed parry rate is lower than it really is because you have an extra level of mitigation to go through first.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CurlyBruce

The point I was making about that is if Shield Blocks have a specific cap, where as Parry has a higher cap, and Shield Blocks are checked first. The increase to Parry from DEX would seem smaller because Shield Blocks are obscuring the data. Say Shield Block is 25% rate but with the same DEX you have a 50% parry rate. You have to fail the shield check first before a parry goes off, and because you can't shield block and parry on the same attack any attack that passes the shield check will register as a block instead of a parry. So your observed parry rate is lower than it really is because you have an extra level of mitigation to go through first.

---

I see your point, but I was referring to the fact that once the shield block activates, the calculations should stop and parry wouldn't be considered. So your sample size would decrease to all hits that shield block missed. In your example, you would have 75% of data that should have 50% worth of parry. The disparity would diminish until you hit a point where you would be covered by one or the other. Also, in your example, parry should be all over the place if it were obscured by shield block.

The fact remains, we still cannot say DEX helps WARs anyway since more time is needed for testing.

EDIT: If it is a hidden modifier for WAR, I would be wary of changes in the future because that sounds like it was lazy balancing.

PS forum limit hit.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CurlyBruce

It would be highly illogical that SE would only add a hidden modifier on a single job out of the 9 jobs in the game, and only DEX when it comes to parry rate.

---

I would not be surprised simply if it was a last minute change to make WARs have slightly better mitigation, with the reasoning being that they miss out on half the passive mitigation of Paladins due to no shield.

i'd like to see these #'s as well just for the hell of it, but i don't put much stock into it.
IMHO the 500 HP for 30 vit isn't that great compared to the bonuses you'd get from stack STR, face it, WAR is a leecher, if you do it right you can leech alot of health. most people think of it as seriously underestimated, but if you think about it and use it right it will save your ass really well. i been watching a bunch of vids on Titan and it would seem that if you saved infuriate + 5 wrath, with high enough str inner beast will easily cure you for 1k+ on a non crit, titan seems to like to save his huge attack for the end of the fight, or at least do it so much that you gotta give your all at the moment.i say save infuriate at that moment cuz you might not need it when you use one inner beast right off the bat, as long as the healers pick you up from there, but if they can't you can infuriate for a second inner beast back to back. now you are giving yourself back nearly half of what your lost on your own, if you are in a party with two WAR, then you could bounce hate, it'd work like this, first tank takes the big hit, whats that 4-7k depending on how much def they have, i know all the youtube vids i see the wars seem to take 4 k but i hear 7 sometimes so for worst case senarios i'll put that number up there(even though if you have crappy enough gear[which i am only 49 atm so i would lol, and wouldn't be even trying til i have better] you shouldn't be even trying) then have the second WAR provoke off(puts him at top of hate list) and take the hate off him for a second, he can even have crappy gear and die but it would work at the end because, it would give you a bit more time to heal main tank, second tank would take the next really big hit and not main, at which time main would take hate back with provoke and be ready for the next one. i'd totally take a dive for this purpose if i had to. i know this part is posible, but your main war would HAVE to have lv 90 gear lol

You should find out if DEX affects Dodge rate too. :)
http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...09#post1342009

The only real benefit for dex stats comes to WAR if the teirs are possible because Shieldblock is so much easier to get and validate and at that point dex would be wasted because your other stats would be more vital; mitigation is what pld has HP is what they don't. Warriors have a bit more freedom because of lack of options make our decisions moot in the grand scheme. And even then that would only benefit in a materia/crafted gear stand point with equations and tiers are rounded off so stat cap for the armor and accessories becomes a hinderance. But warrior who persues it could reduce their overall damage taken and increase effiency which with no solace of hallow ground and sentinel is important. This will not be a replacement for vit though its is our biggest tool when paired with sch bubble. Comparing Dex to vit is like comparing vit to mnd for pld. Sure it can increase your heals but at what cost?