Dark Knight Megathread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Absurdity

It matters when it comes to damage variance. Having all your potency spread out between multiple abilities means you do not suffer quite as much from that ability not critting. If a majority of your damage is in 1-2 abilities it can make your overall dps jump wildly depending on whether or not those abilities crit under the 30%+ buff windows.

But ask the Gunbreakers how it feels when Double Down doesn't crit during your 2-min burst.

---

Personally IDGF. The game shouldn't be designed around parsers who obsess over whether one more lucky crit pushes their rank up a few spots.

I mean yeah obviously, you wouldn't make Double Down a million potency and every other oGCD 1 potency, where that kind of random chance would actually start to become a deal breaker for clearing content, but you understand what I mean. Potencies going up doesn't in itself mean anything all things being relative.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Somnolence

Other tank potencies increased more.

Looks like based on potency / second its GNB > WAR > PLD > DRK.

DRK has highest 2min, so if you got a static where buffs are nicely aligning maybe actual dps will be good, but in random PF or DF it might be meh.

---

Last I saw it was actually GNB > PLD > WAR > DRK
Dark Knight was already doing the most damage so this isn't really suprising, but beyond that the potency bumps per minute are so close as they are that I wouldn't expect anything to change.
The difference is 38 potency per minute between GNB and DRK, with the difference being 5 potency between WAR and DRK.

That said I think its been like this for a while now, and the 2m alignment basically flips it to being DRK favored.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ThorneDynasty

Personally IDGF. The game shouldn't be designed around parsers who obsess over whether one more lucky crit pushes their rank up a few spots.

I mean yeah obviously, you wouldn't make Double Down a million potency and every other oGCD 1 potency, where that kind of random chance would actually start to become a deal breaker for clearing content, but you understand what I mean. Potencies going up doesn't in itself mean anything all things being relative.

---

I get what you mean, I couldn't care less about which attack had what potency if the gameplay were actually any good.
But if I have to choose between terrible gameplay and massive crit issues or terrible gameplay and no crit issues I'll take the latter.

Then again I absolutely detest the potency bloat we've been getting for like 3 expansions now anyway.
Remember when Fell Cleave was the highest potency attack in the game with a potency of 500?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Oizen

Last I saw it was actually GNB > PLD > WAR > DRK
Dark Knight was already doing the most damage so this isn't really suprising, but beyond that the potency bumps per minute are so close as they are that I wouldn't expect anything to change.
The difference is 38 potency per minute between GNB and DRK, with the difference being 5 potency between WAR and DRK.

That said I think its been like this for a while now, and the 2m alignment basically flips it to being DRK favored.

---

This is quoted as a source: https://x.com/FfxivYasu/status/18062...AwKc3L6OA&s=19 job left column translations are knight warrior dark, gunplay, first column overall dmg, second during 2min.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Somnolence

This is quoted as a source: https://x.com/FfxivYasu/status/18062...AwKc3L6OA&s=19 job left column translations are knight warrior dark, gunplay, first column overall dmg, second during 2min.

---

The tweet says War will do more over 6 minutes under buffs too lmao
If that ever happens you might as well just delete all the other tanks.

guys please review my dark knight rework: https://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/...hield-Mechanic

Not that I can give much still being 90 and all that, but Shadowstride doesn't feel very good to use. There's a brief delay there that never happened with plunge, and while it's not too crazy it does feel very awkward.

Although, in comparison to GNB... we got off lucky! Sorta. :o

Sorry but even with the new scarlet delirum combo (I unlocked it), the mp gain is exactly the same, so we still lost 1200Mp minutes with the lost of 2 stack of BW, its very urgent to fix that !

Which mean bloodweapon only give 1800 mp?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by The_User

Which mean bloodweapon only give 1800 mp?

---

In Endwalker it is 600mp per hit of BW and 200mp per hit of bloodspiller with delirium, 3 stack of bloodspiller under delirium, and 5 stack of BW, each stack of bloodspiller with delirium effect grant 200MP and each stack of BW give 600MP per hit, so 3 x 200 and 5 x 600. so 3600MP each minutes.
Now, the MP value gain per hit is exactly the same, but we have 3 stack of BW instead of 5, and scarlet delirium combo dont change anything of the MP Gain value, so we still lost 1200 MP per minutes, we gain only 2400MP.