Basically my thoughts as well. I don't particularly enjoy crafting as such, but still, if we're going to have crafting-based content then I would prefer it to be my character crafting things themself for their own goals rather than tasking a horde of annoying mammets to craft arbitrary things for faceless consumers.
At very least, I would like the crafts to tie into supplying groups and causes we are personally acquainted with.
But overall when they said "peaceful island escape", optimising a spreadsheet is about as far from my expectations as possible.
Carteneau has been used a few times. The instance you're thinking of is right at the end of 5.55 but there was an earlier one as well – I think 4.55 when we were activating Omega to fight Shinryu, and it has also been used in a summoner job quest (as has Seal Rock).
