Todays Demographics within FFXIV

While it's doubtful.. I'm tempted to say this has been the most thoughtful and devious troll thread I've seen this year. Single post count user, no replies, innocuously contentious content that has people arguing instantly.


*Golf clap*

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Iscah

"The Americas", sure (and it's a name implying ther there are at least two of them), but I've never seen the whole double-continent landmass referred to as simply "America". That means USA to the vast majority of people.

Perhaps it's used differently in America itself.

In any case you should be wanting to separate out the continents of North America and South America simply because "The Americas" is such a huge geographical range that you want to split it out in your data.

Continent-wise, "Central America" is still part of North America.

---

Our master-geologist became a master-scientist.


I believe OP thought about that while creating his/her thesis.

This poor thread.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Krotoan

While it's doubtful.. I'm tempted to say this has been the most thoughtful and devious troll thread I've seen this year. Single post count user, no replies, innocuously contentious content that has people arguing instantly.


*Golf clap*

---

Well, if I try to get some data, I would ask in as many social groups as possible to get a variety of data. And of course I wouldn't play all of those games.

The muricans making fun of themselves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by LianaThorne

Is Canada considered part of the US/North America? No. It's its own country.
Source: https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/...of-the-us.html

Is Mexico considered part of the US/North America? No, it's its own country between North and South America. It's not even part of Central America.
Source: https://www.spanish.academy/blog/is-...ntral-america/

Is South America part of the US/North America? No, it's its own continent that is a part of the "Americas" but they do not recognize themselves as the general "American" that the US does (hence why Brazilian, Chilean, etc. exists):
Source: https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/...continent.html

It really isn't hard to Google. Just because it's all a giant landmass does not mean everyone there recognizes themselves as American lmao.

---

what does the USA stand for... United States of what? Hmm I wonder.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SturmChurro

When people say "America" they are usually referring to the US. If it's labeled "the Americas", then sure. So, I can understand any confusion. For demographic purposes, I do think it helps to separate north and south though, and/or latin america.

---

^ This.

For anybody still wondering, yeah, I'm Canadian. I do not consider myself as "American" or living in "America." Of course Canada is part of the continent of North America; that's indisputable. I wasn't trying to give OP a hard time, or turn up my nose at my neighbours to the south -- I just found the choice of words amusing. Also, as others have pointed out, you'd probably get more valuable demographic data splitting up North and South America, rather than keeping it to some vague Western Hemisphere area.

Hey, not to get off-topic, but I just found out about this obscure little movie. Maybe some of you have heard of it:

https://i.imgur.com/9QpCgR8.png

I'm wondering where it takes place. Canada? Brazil? Venezuela? Mexico? Chile? It could be almost anywhere! If only there were some cultural clues... but of course, something something Amerigo Vespucci 500 years ago, there's just no way to know!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fyrebrand

Hey, not to get off-topic, but I just found out about this obscure little movie. Maybe some of you have heard of it:

https://i.imgur.com/9QpCgR8.png

I'm wondering where it takes place. Canada? Brazil? Venezuela? Mexico? Chile? It could be almost anywhere! If only there were some cultural clues... but of course, something something Amerigo Vespicci 500 years ago, there's just no way to know!

---

That's disingenuous.

The cover clearly shows the race and attire of one of the characters and you should expect to know where the story is taking place.

Just like it's disingenuous to purposefully misinterpret words because you don't like to identify with a certain aspect of culture.
You knew they were talking about the Americas but chose to understand it as they were talking about the USA.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nethereal

The cover clearly shows the race and attire of one of the characters and you should expect to know where the story is taking place.

---

https://i.imgur.com/0gRDSQB.gif

Oooooooh no... Please, no. This cannot be seriously be happening...

Look, I know where American Psycho takes place. I was being a bit cheeky before, to make a point.

But I have to ask: what "race" do you think the guy on the American Psycho cover is, and how does that tell you where he's from? You may be surprised to find out Christian Bale is originally from the UK. So, not "America" by any standard.

Also, "attire"? Do you think there is only one country on earth where they wear a suit and tie? People wear that all over the world!

Seems to me, the main signifier of where the movie takes place is actually the word "American." Not that there is some white dude wearing a suit.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fyrebrand

https://i.imgur.com/0gRDSQB.gif

Oooooooh no... Please, no. This cannot be seriously be happening...

Look, I know where American Psycho takes place. I was being a bit cheeky before, to make a point.

But I have to ask: what "race" do you think the guy on the American Psycho cover is, and how does that tell you where he's from? You may be surprised to find out Christian Bale is originally from the UK. So, not "America" by any standard.

Also, "attire"? Do you think there is only one country on earth where they wear a suit and tie? People wear that all over the world!

Seems to me, the main signifier of where the movie takes place is actually the word "American." Not that there is some white dude wearing a suit.

---

Even If I were to ignore the fact you're comparing a movie title to a question in a survey listing continents that would still be disingenuous.

This isn't a question of whether you were or are being disingenuous, you are/where, you admitted to it:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fyrebrand

I just found the choice of words amusing.

---

You understood what was being asked and the appropriate answer but you intentionally decided against properly answering.
It was a joke and that's okay, it wasn't meant to be taken seriously.

Its disingenuous because you're using the same logic you used on your first post as the one you're using on the post I originally quoted.
You're purposefully misrepresenting the difficulty and the knowledge required to properly participate.
I.E. you're pretending it's confusing for the sake of doing it.

You don't need cultural clues to know that a movie featuring an English title with a Caucasian male in a suit will be focused around the US.
If it's in English and the title is literally "The American Psycho" it's probably being produced by Hollywood, Hollywood is in America, specifically the US.
Now if for some reason the above wasn't the case that would simply be bad marketing.
Why? Because America is often used synonymously and interchangeably with the US.

But a movie title isn't the same thing as a survey asking where you're from especially when continents are being listed.

It has nothing to do with the US, Americans, or America and everything to do with interpreting the text in good faith the way it was presented in its context.

Context is king. There was a survey, there was a question, there was an answer. You didn't like the answer, that's okay. Just don't pretend you didn't understand the answer.

What is happening in this thread?