Should Clemency be nerfed?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kaynide

I would even say give PLD a sort of Raise spell with long cooldown.

---

Would have to be like BLU's and maybe oGCD

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DragonFlyy

I wish there were more tank heals like Clemency. Makes my job as a healer easier.

---

Tank DPS is usually better than heal. They should be DPSing not healing themselves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PharisHanasaki

Healing is probably the easiest role now.

I dislike it when tanks and rdm start healing themselves when not needed. Leaves me with even less things to do.

---

One of those pure healers huh? If your party members are healthy you should be dpsing.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hysterior

Tank DPS is usually better than heal. They should be DPSing not healing themselves.

---

Not by much, they're roughly equal on single target. But on AoE situations, a good healer can do insanely good damage.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DragonFlyy

Disagree. I wish there were more tank heals like Clemency. Makes my job as a healer easier.

---

Probably one of the reasons OP fearedit being a "player trap". That said...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Hysterior

Tank DPS is usually better than heal. They should be DPSing not healing themselves.

---

If a Healer or both are dead, then the lifeline is lost (bar a RDM or SMN being in the party), and DPS should then be a secondary concern until their back in their feet (unless its a DPS check, in which case all is usually lost anyway) so having self sustain would be worth it if it can salvage the run and prevent wipes

Otherwise, yeah, Tanks should prioritize DPS, mayhap this is also why OP fears it being a player trap as well

Clemency should probably be one of the skills to go in the next culling. Like the only reason you should really be using it is if you are trying to solo old content.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRealQuah

Clemency should probably be one of the skills to go in the next culling. Like the only reason you should really be using it is if you are trying to solo old content.

---

Only if they get rid of all other tank sustain abilities.

And might as well get rid of healer dps skills too.

And rdms heal, second wind, dps raises, etc. Let's just get rid of all job flavor while we're at it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheRealQuah

Clemency should probably be one of the skills to go in the next culling. Like the only reason you should really be using it is if you are trying to solo old content.

---

Figures a dark knight might feel that way. Sorry but it's a really cool paladin skill and should stay right where it is. Nothing more entertaining to watch heals go down and have a pally do his thing and take on the boss all alone keeping dps up and running as well.

it's good because you lose dps everytime you use it, other tanks do not lose any with their heals.

Who on earth even uses clemency when playing competitively? xD

And why should we even consider balancing the game on casual level?

When i see paladin wasting his combo for clemency as a healer, i want to grab them and throw them into oblivion. I would appreciate the change however, clemency as a oGCD with 2.5 sec cooldown and MP cost, would be a nice thing to have.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Liam_Harper

Just look at how neutered or clunky things like Abyssal Drain or Nascent Flash are, because they can't let tanks be self-sufficient.

---

I'll give you Abyssal Drain being clunky, but Nascent Flash is overpowered and should be nerfed if any tank healing ability needs to be nerfed.