Please put a range limitation on shield lob / tomahawk

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Symbiant

Exactly! It's just out of melee range just as I have requested.

No one said to tab target mobs. If you are doing a group right you will not have to target but one mob.

---

Bad tank is bad.

Sometimes a lob is needed for that extra aggro, and it's off GCD, so if you're in a RoH combo on 2 mobs, and the third one turns to the healer, if provoke is down or mp is low (which happens a lot when spamming flash), it's a viable attack.

Why remove/limit an ability in a tank's bag just for emersion? It's a fantasy game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Eggnook24

Bad tank is bad.

Sometimes a lob is needed for that extra aggro, and it's off GCD, so if you're in a RoH combo on 2 mobs, and the third one turns to the healer, if provoke is down or mp is low (which happens a lot when spamming flash), it's a viable attack.

Why remove/limit an ability in a tank's bag just for emersion? It's a fantasy game.

---

Shield lob is not off GCD lol

Shield lob is quick aggro grasp tool besides Flash. All first move in any combo for Pal or War does not gave aggro generator built-in. I still don't see what to justify for the change??? And for the sake of argument, let say it is changed, don't blame us if we can not get the aggro back fast enough, and you are dead because of that. I can so see that coming, like really, no kidding....Please, use your intelligent better, please!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kerwin

Requires combo. And overpowered is less range and costs more tp. This is my last post to this troll thread

---

Ignoring Defiance/ShOath:

Uncomboed Halone/Butcher is 100x5 = 500
Overpower is 120x5 = 600
Lob/Hawk is 130x3 = 390
Uncomboed Skull/Savage is 100x3 = 300

Lob/Hawk isn't that great.

Overpower is a whopping 3y less.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Symbiant

I never said anything about being angry about it. I just said I would like it changed.

It's a ranged attack and imo if you are in melee then it is not ranged. It's more of discrepancy issue then anything.

---

no melee range attacks for BRD

Of all the things that need to be improved, you pick this to dedicate an entire thread to?

Just no.

Move along folks, nothing to see here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Symbiant

You can't shoulder tackle unless you are @ a certain range. I can shoulder tackle someone within punching range in real life.

---

This is just as stupid as saying bards shouldnt be able to fire arrows at melee range.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Symbiant

Exactly! It\\'s just out of melee range just as I have requested

No one said to tab target mobs. If you are doing a group right you will not have to target but one mob.

---

Only.target.one.mob.in.a.pull....

I need a sec....





Ok.

You should be constantly doing your rotation on the whole group because healers generate agro on EVERYTHING you have pulled.

Also to guy above I think your confusing provoke with lob, provoke is off GCD.

I play on PS4. My Lob is a Macro which also puts Mark #1.
Therefore I always start a fight with lob so DPS knows which to go for. During my combos, I normally use the lob to put marker on new target.
I do that on the cooldown so I don't actually Lob noone, just apply the number. But sometimes I end up lobbing when the cooldown finished.


Anyways, I don't see a point in not allowing the skills to be cast.
If you don't like, don't cast. Not everyone is noob/troll like you :D

Also, this:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Riepah

Then any attack of Archer or Bard would need a minimum range by that logic.

---

ehh? it doesn't break the game and changing it wouldn't make people better players.

perhaps figure out ways to spend TP more efficiently rather than requesting for a change