Queue times will skyrocket and you'll swap the "I got left behind watching cutscenes" threads for the "Why do I have an 8 hour queue?" threads. Personally I think the long queues are a worse problem.
Printable View
If it makes you feel more justified, the story makes it clear that you're leading a group into the Praetorium.
Even if you don't lift a finger, it was your leading the unit in that makes you a hero. After all, no one wants their general killed in battle.
I like this angle! I may try role-playing it when I start running this in the future, if at least to try comforting other players running it for the first time so their experience isn't as awkward as mine. Maybe something like:
/p Roll call: Who's doing this for the first time?
/p Okay, good. We pledge our blades and skills to your service.
/kneel
/p Sit back and enjoy the story at your leisure. We're going to forge ahead and clear the path for you.
/p All we ask is that you do the same for future heroes one day.
/gcsalute
That's the idea. MAKE it unappealing for tome grinders (especially when you consider there are so many other options for them). If there are less people running it just for tomes, there'll be less cases of speed-runners/tome-grinders surging ahead of those who are new and negatively impacting the experience.
At the same time, so as not to seem totally focused on "preserving the experience for first-timers" there is still incentive with gil and GC seals. Perhaps other reward incentives besides tomes can be implemented. But largely, the idea is to make it less about speed-running for tomes and more for helping people complete the story and still get something out of it personally.
No, they don't. Which is why outside of the mandatory run for story completion, most don't do it.
This isn't a problem that'll be fixed easily, and to be honest, even I can't think of a good, "everyone-wins" solution. But as for the problem of "speed runners leaving behind newbies just for tomes" issue, that's a fairly easy one to fix. Make it less appealing.
Sure, Brayflox gets old. But you can literally get tomes almost anywhere now. It may not be at maximum or the most time-efficient methods, you can get them anywhere. So why something lengthy like Praetorium?